Sunday, April 17, 2016

My Log 513 April 16 2016: Cree survivor, now an educationalist, Dr George Blacksmith sums up the impact of residential schools on his people in a painful new book

St. Paul's Indian Industrial School, Middlechu...
St. Paul's Indian Industrial School, Middlechurch, Manitoba (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Formerly St. Michael's Residential School Buil...
Formerly St. Michael's Residential School Building, Alert Bay. Turned over to 'Namgis First Nation and renamed 'Namgis House in 2003. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)



FORGOTTEN FOOTPRINTS: Colonialism from a Cree perspective: the
Social and Psychological Impact of Residential Schools on the James Bay Cree of Northern Quebec, by Dr George Blacksmith. 175 pages, Published by  the Gordon Group, Ottawa.

George Blacksmith was a small Cree boy of five when, in 1955,  he was subjected to a social experiment decreed by the government of Canada, and administered on its behalf largely by the Anglican, Roman Catholic, United and Presbyterian religions. He was  sent off, a trembling bewildered child leaving his home for the first time, to an Indian residential school whose objective was to detach Indian children from the “barbarous” lifestyles of their parents. Now, as Dr.  Blacksmith, describing himself as a survivor (just) , by this time with  a B.A (in education), an M.A. (in educational administration and policy studies), a Ph.D (in educational studies), and a lifetime of teaching and administrative work behind him, he has written a book that describes the experience so pitilessly that it is, at times, difficult to read.
I remember when I first went among the Crees of James Bay in 1969, one of the first things I learned of them was that a McGill University study had discovered that 25 per cent of their pre-and teenage children were already suffering from clinically observable depression. In any other population in Canada this would have aroused a fire storm of protest and objection. But not to worry, they were only Crees. They were only subsistence hunters, 6,000 or so of them, occupying a huge territory, at least as large as France, that, in the general opinion of Canadians, could be, and should be, put to better use for the extraction of  minerals and lumber.
That such a brutal, ignorant and prejudiced policy should ever have been administered in Canada is something that is still hard to believe. I remember how, a few years ago, when I occasionally talked to college students about how their country has treated its aboriginal population, many of them found it hard to believe such things had happened here.  Dr Blacksmith, too, is still busy trying to educate his fellows, and when I talked to him by phone the other day, he had just returned from a session in a Cree school, whose students, like many of those I had met, were almost reluctant to believe what he was telling them.
“I cannot say I’ve fully recovered from the ordeal of my residential school experience, or if I ever will,” he writes. “On leaving school I went back to my roots for five years to find true healing…. Today I am very  proud to have regained my language. I have become a skilled hunter and well-versed in the ways of my people and understand the language of the Elders. I have now been educated in two cultural traditions and understand the distinct content and structural differences inherent in each. I can survive in both worlds and comfortably live in harmony and walk with nature. My tongue no longer hurts when I speak my language.
“When I talk about my culture and express my pride in my people, I am no longer ashamed of who I am. I now accept what has happened to me. I turned to my people for healing on the land and personally took concrete steps, through work and schooling, to stop being a prisoner of the system or a hostage to despair. I did not let Canada’s aboriginal education policy control the direction I needed to take in my life. I decided to ask for forgiveness from those I have hurt --- my family and friends --- for my negative actions due to the personal pain and suffering I endured. Yet, at the same time, I have struggled with my own conscience for years to offer my forgiveness to those who did me wrong in the hope that their lives, too, can now go on.”
I think it would be good if everyone aspiring to any sort of leadership in Canada could read these words, to give them an idea of some of the grimmer realities of life in this country. I am writing this as news is being distributed about a reserve in northern Ontario just across the bay from Dr Blacksmith’s homeland,  where eleven children attempted to commit suicide in one day a week or so ago, and today it is reported that another five children have attempted suicide. If we cannot respond decisively to such a tragic call for help, whatever will we ever respond to?
When I was first confronted with the puzzle of trying to figure out what might be the best way forward for the depressed native population, the first thing that seemed necessary was that they should recover their pride in their history, beliefs, practices, and culture. After that, they needed something of the white man’s education so as to equip them to handle the powerful governmental and business machines that constantly confront them. I am pleased to find that this has been George Blacksmith’s opinion, too. for he speaks of first going back to his roots, educating himself in the traditional life in the bush, learning the skills traditional among his people. Many white observers in recent years, newly aware of the native people and their difficulties, have concluded that the answer lies in assimilation. As this book demonstrates, this is arrant nonsense, because it ignores that assimilation has always been the policy, and is directly responsible for the current condition.
The residential schools had existed almost since the passing of the Indian Act in 1876, but they did not really affect the Cree of northern Quebec until the 1930s. By an accident of history these people had been been almost left alone by Canadian governing authorities. For generations they were serviced through Hudson’s Bay directly from Britain by the Hudson’s Bay Company, which has always operated trading posts --- now more likely retail stores --- in the communities throughout the region. The Bay had always provided the minimal goods the hunters --- transformed into trappers to meet the needs of the fur trade --- took with them into their traplines, and they came to collect the furs in time to transport them to  the coast and back to Scotland each year. The relative isolation of the people from outside influences was what enabled them to keep a coherent hunting culture together, their language under no threat for generations, and their beliefs and practices more or less intact in spite of their acceptance of the Anglican missions who came to them from 1840 onwards.  
But the 1930s brought a railway into the southern reaches of their territory, and that brought white trappers who had no idea of living in harmony with other creatures and quickly cleared out the beaver.  James Watt was a notable Hudson’s Bay factor who helped establish a system under which the beaver recovered, allowing the trappers eventually to administer their own subsistence life as it continued through to the imposition of the James Bay hydro project on them in 1971.
Dr Blacksmith in his book has divided the victims of the residential school system into three generations. The First Generation were those taken into the schools (with the reluctant acquiescence of their parents) from the early 1930s through the 1950s. The Second Generation were people like George himself, and he describes his experience in these words, calmly, but with dramatic effect: “I have been institutionalized for fifteen years of my life. I have personally experienced language and cultural deprivation, family separation, physical and psychological abuse and also experienced the sexual acts of abuse that have shattered the lives of many of my friends from the Cree communities of James Bay.” (Elsewhere in the book he speaks of undergoing a forty-five year drug and alcohol-related addiction, arising from those schooltime experiences)
He allows others of his acquaintance to provide their own testimonies to the impact of these experiences on their lives and those around them.  It is clear that this brutal schooling has carried over into crippled personal lives in the communities.  The list of effects is long and Dr Blacksmith  describes them in great detail: lack of parenting skills, deliberately  inculcated feelings of worthlessness, loss of contact with the original culture and of the skills needed by it, depressions and and other psychological effects --- all these have been among the most drastic effects  of  this so-called educational experience.
The Third Generation are students who have gone  in more recent times to schools that have been often in or close to the communities they serve, “but (these schools) brought with them the same attitudes and three generations of legacy,” Dr. Blacksmith comments. These students have years later been affected by parents and grandparents who are still trying to come to terms with what they have undergone in this immense and totally bizarre social experiment, leaving with them as it has feelings of guilt and betrayal that have become endemic.
Dr. Blacksmith deals with Stephen Harper’s sort-of apology for the residential school system. “In his apology Prime Minister Harper, while not fully understanding the magnitude of the impacts of government policies, acknowledged its ongoing effects,” he comments. “Yet no one from the government ranks has made any meaningful commitment to foster positive change, especially for our young people.”
It is to be hoped that the new government will do better; but it is notable that the aboriginal people are wary of their promises, and are waiting for more concrete proof of their goodwill.
In the last chapters of his book Dr. Blacksmith, who knows whereof he speaks, expresses his dissatisfaction with the results achieved by the Cree School Board now nominally under the control of the Cree, but yet hampered by having to adhere to the Quebec school curriculums and standards. “The same issues in education we had ten years before the James Bay and Northern Quebec Agreement are still issues today,” he writes.
“There are many assumptions made by outside experts regarding Cree education. As valuable as children are, it is difficult to understand why many of our experts on Cree education continue to impose Western educational assumptions instead of searching for a deeper understanding and a solution to the problems.”
One of the problems here is that the white invaders from Europe assumed that the native people they came in contact with had no system of education at all. Such attitudes obviously still persist. “Traditional education included  the spiritual, physical, social and cultural connection to the land. When the newcomers arrived, the Cree people noticed that the newcomers looked at the land and its resources from an ownership perspective. Many of them considered land something they must possess --- a commodity, which they could sell to make a profit --- and looked at owning all of its resources and eventually establishing their own communities to control the assets…. For the Cree people taking care of the health of the land --- its creatures and water --- was a daily teaching where there were no lesson plans, but all activities were interrelated and central to the survival of their traditional practices.”
Here we come to the nub of the problem: the traditional attitudes and beliefs of the indigenous people are radically different from those of the invaders, but Dr. Blacksmith is too wise to believe his people can manage in the modern world without taking advantage of modern knowledge and learning.
I hope this book gets wide distribution, especially among our decision-makers. The signs for it are good. Published apparently by the Gordon Group, 334 Churchill avenue north, Ottawa, a company with commercial links to the Cree governing bodies, it has been  issued in 1,000 copies, which have been snapped up within the Cree communities, leading to a second printing of 5,000.
Apart from anything else, it is a remarkable testimony to the life experiences of people whose understanding of nature, whose perceptions about the place of human beings among other creatures on this earth, although constantly under attack, are now needed by all of us as never before.







Tuesday, April 12, 2016

My Log 512 April 12 2016: At last, an answer emerges to my question of 38 years ago: what has happened to the Chinese watertables

I read today that a government study in China has revealed that 80 per cent of the
Rewi Alley about when I met him


Alley in his younger days


country’s groundwaters are too contaminated for human consumption. Although the study did not include the deeper wells that most large cities use, it is still true that most Chinese live in the countryside whose towns and villages depend on shallower wells for drinking water (and for other uses).
This really takes me back to 1978, when I was in China as part of a National Film Board crew making films, a programme set up by the two governments. The first film we made was about a rural commune, successfully growing two crops a year on land that we would regard as marginal. I was fascinated by their system of agriculture and of governance, and peppered them with questions for the six extremely productive weeks we were working with them.
 I realized these rural cadres were unused to fielding such questions from an outside busybody like me, but I honoured them in that, after some delay, they gave me the information I sought, eventually producing a guy in a singelet with a little notebook in which all of the figures for recent production, income and expenditure were entered, and which he laboriously read out to me. He was the commune’s accountant, it seems, this working man in a t-shirt.  
We were able to see with our own eyes most of the results these figures revealed, for the commune which was groaning under a heavy wheat crop when we arrived in May, by July as we were leaving had been replanted and reconfigured into a rice paddy. Similarly, we had seen with our own eyes how everything, every single thing that grew, was used and recycled into their system, nothing, absolutely nothing, wasted; among the figures they gave me was the amount of manure produced in their backyards by the pig owned by each peasant household, and sold to the commune or brigade farms. Chairman Mao in the 1950s had recommended in a speech that every peasant household should own a pig. And I figured out that the people of Wushing commune, collectively and individually,  were raising 6,000 pigs, and were producing  something like 100,000 tonnes a year of organic manure. This, along with the water pumped up by the wells, was the basis for the success of their agriculture. 
We travelled quite a bit around the country on this trip, enough to convince me that this commune, although one of the better ones, was by no means just a model farm of the sort they had used nationally for propaganda purposes, and around which they had erected all sorts of production figures that, not long after we left, were revealed to have been figments of the imagination of the managers. We were there to watch the grain grow, and we were there for its harvesting, in which 13,000 of the 15,000 people living in the commune’s four villages, including all the schoolchildren, were deeply involved (the aged and the ailing being exempt from the task). We filmed as they worked through the night to get the grain in, and we filmed as cart-load after cart-load left to carry it to markets in the nearby towns. It was this massive effort, most of it unsupported by grants from senior levels of government, that gave me my intense admiration for the Chinese people, and for the government that was striving to do a work on which everyone, after all, has a central interest, which is that the people of the world, including the poorest, must be fed. Is it any wonder I felt impelled to find out, if I could, exactly how they were doing all this?
I felt there was only one question I kept on asking them that they studiously avoided.
“You say that on these 3,000 acres in the commune, you have sunk 308 wells which are the basis for your agricultural success. If you are typical, across the North China plain [which was described at the time by a Western expert as ‘the greatest collection of agricultural communities on earth’], there must be many thousands of recently drilled wells. What effect is this having on the water table?” was my question.
The answer was always the same, repeated as if by rote: “That is the problem of the department concerned,” they said.  In other words, they didn’t know, and couldn’t find out, which was a pretty fair indication that no one knew. The nation, desperate to feed one quarter of the world’s population, and that one quarter among the very poorest people on earth, was boxing on, hoping the problem could be delayed.
As it happens on that visit to China I had a conversation with a man who had been a hero of mine ever since my childhood. This man, Rewi Alley, went to China in 1929, became a factory inspector in the internationally-dominated port of Shanghai, and had lived in China ever since. He was so appalled by what he saw of working conditions in the factory that he set up training schools, financed by foreign money from American, Australian and New Zealand  volunteers. The Japanese invasion in the 1930s eventually destroyed his schools, so he decided to retreat to the far corners of the country where he would build a school to train rural leaders that would make all its own materials. Over the years he became a legendary figure for us in New Zealand. And when the Communists took over China in 1949, he realized they were about to do on a national scale what he had been doing locally on a tiny individual scale.  The new government agreed his work could continue but without foreign monetary support.
Eventually, Alley’s school was incorporated into the national system, and he  became one of that handful of dedicated foreigners who lived on through all of China’s traumas to become a propagandist for the Communist regime. Not long before our visit he had turned 80, and the occasion was graced by a dinner at which all of the major leaders of the country were present.
During our travels I spotted him dining with some Chinese men on the other side of a restaurant. I made bold to approach him. He said he had been told some Canadians were wanting to talk to him, but he was he was sorry he was really too busy to comply. Half an hour later, however, he got up, came to our table, and chatted, and I joined him later for an interview in his hotel room.
He had no worries he said, about the Chinese being able to make things. They were a resourceful and clever people, and would have no trouble in producing goods. What worried him was how would they feed themselves? Every year, they had to overcome some terrible natural calamity, a massive flood, a drought, an earthquake. (Only a year or so before our visit there had been an earthquake which some foreign experts still believe killed 600,000 people, and even the government admits killed 250,000. In those years China was still doing everything alone, depending on its own resources, accepting no foreign help, and giving out little information about its disasters.) So whatever effort they made to catch up on the food deficit, said Alley, was reduced in effect as they strove to overcome these calamities.
Of course, he said, they have dug wells all over the country to sustain their crops: but his worry was, the water table. What were going to be the effects of the countless wells they had drilled in order to nurture the crops, now growing all over the country, for the first time in at least their recent centuries?
The very question I had been asking my contacts in the commune, and the answers to which are only now coming to the surface in the form of contaminated and sparse water resources, apparently increasingly  incapable of sustaining the immense pressure placed on them.
With China now almost the entire world’s factory, in fulfillment of Rewi Alley’s view of their mechanical abilities, the shortage of water is only one of the many immense problems facing this country, as it tries to fight a way into a successful future. No one should underestimate the immense efforts they have been making since at 1949. And now, perhaps more than ever before, we all have a stake in their success. 













Sunday, April 10, 2016

My Log 511 April 10 2016 I take in a piece of Americana: a Texan Motor Show full of hot rods and vintage cars, and rock and roll bands, and lots of noise

Steve Wertheimer
(picture by John Anderson, Austin  Chronicle)



Yesterday I attended an event that I think could be called a piece of real Americana, or to be more precise, of Texicarna. It was the annual Motor Show in Austin, Texas. It is an event I witnessed a few years ago, on what I remember was a stifling hot day as we walked across the hills on the outskirts of the city, on which vintage cars from all over the United States had been gathered to be admired by the populace.

I am not interested in vintage or any other cars, but my son has an interest in this event because it is staged by a man he has known ever since he moved down here 12 years ago, a man who owns a famous Austin nightclub, the Continental, and who helped Ben and his band, Grady, in many ways over the years.
This man, Steve Wertheimer, could also be described as typically American, a self-made capitalist who moved into a depressed area of the city when he bought his nightclub, and who has since, by judicious investments in this and that, not only become extremely wealthy himself, but has been agent for uplifting the entire neighbourhood until today it is a thrusting, successful area for business and entertainment.
The stereotypes that would spring to mind for me of such a man would be mostly negative ones. But Steve, a restlessly energetic man, sort of defies most of those stereotypes. He is, of course hard-headed in business, as which businessman isn’t, but if his nightclub is anything to judge him by, there seems to be a real human being operating in that effervescent body. The Continental, as I have written many times, is still a grungy sort of dark hole entirely suitable for its mission, as laid down by its owner, that of playing live music on every day of the year, opening at 4 pm, and playing until closing time, usually around 2 am. Or maybe 3 am, if the gig is rocking.  He sticks to that mission so punctiliously that every Christmas Day there is a traditional gig by one of Austin’s favorite musicians, Dale Watson, who for four or five hours without a break just keeps playing some of the thousands of songs in his vocabulary until any reasonable man would be more likely to collapse than to keeping singing on.
There are said to be 150 such clubs in Austin that have live music, but certainly the Continental must rank among the top three or four: it is a music scene that enables Austin to claim it is the music capital of the United States. But the city is increasing in size --- up to 950,000 from 250,000 in 1970 --- at a rocketing rate, accepting as many as 100 new residents every day who, some say, are threatening to overwhelm the traditional Austin life style, of which music is probably its central core.  There are certainly still many wonderful musicians, great bands, in Austin, superb instrumentalists of the jazz, rock and pop variety. And Steve Wertheimer is one of those who bestrides this world ---- and I think I could use this word --- relentlessly. Anyway, since he got his start many years ago in a nightclub run by an old black man, now deceased, he has recently opened a smart new club named C’Boy’s Heart and Soul after  C’Boy Parks his ancient benefactor. It’s the sort of gesture that one might almost expect from a millionaire who  in his struggle to the top has managed to stay more or less a regular  guy (underneath that ruthless business exterior).
As Steve said, quoted in the Austin chronicle, "I think of him every day," of C'Boy. And the newspaper concluded. "Help people.  That's what Henry Wertheimer (Steve's Dad) and C'Boy Parks taught their boy Steve. You help people to help yourself. Fill a room with music and folks who love it, and sometimes it becomes a palace. You've just gotta walk through that door." I like that: it describes more or less how I feel about the Continental, which I have visited dozens of times.
So Steve’s motor show is part vintage cars, and part music. Vintage car guys, hot rodders,  love to make a hell of a racket as they whoosh, rumble and vroom  their engines while the car remains stationary, but needless to say in a show mixing cars with live music, some timetable must be established to allow the sublime to make its itself heard alongside the whooshers and swooshers.  In this environment the bands are as loud as the cars, and the audience, accustomed to the racket of American life, seem to eat it up. In fact, in the evening, at a musical gig attached to the Motor Show that took place in the Austin Speed Shop, I am told that one of the world’s loudest bands was playing as  a vintage car was wheeled into the auditorium, whooshing,  roaring and snarling so loudly that the music was completely drowned out.
I suppose similar events must take place in Canada, but when I remarked on how many overweight people were in attendance, whoever was with me remarked simply, “This is Texas.” That is the response given for almost everything down here. Texans think of themselves as exceptions to whatever rules govern the rest of the country, but to be fair to the state,  interlopers like me are more likely to remark on the obesity, the redneck politics --- “the odious Ted Cruz,” as I saw the Presidential aspirant called in a European journal last week --- the serving of food on greased brown paper, even in popular restaurants, the roughneck boastful posture so often adopted, than we are to remark on the magnificent art galleries, the multifarious universities, the splendidly effulgent public buildings, all of which are equally marks of Texan life.
Well, to get back to the Motor Show. I am sure events similar to this are held in Canada as well, but I am never likely to go to them, and I was astounded by the evidence of the devotion obviously lavished on the restitution of worn out old cars that, when restored, shine and glisten in their new paint, their spotless, gleaming, usually silver, engines, to such as point that I began almost to think of them as works of art. Certainly they are evidence of lives spent in which probably every spare moment and every spare dollar is devoted to the task. Some of the old beauties were for sale, with price tags for a 1931 roadster, for example, of $65,000, a rather impressive sum to pay for a vehicle the actual use of which must be minimal.  From restoration it is usually just an object to sit in the museum and be looked at.
And in the surrounding tents, where the businesspeople who serve this underground industry had their stalls, the things that people have made a hobby or a business of saving, and converting into cash are of almost indescribable variety. One item that struck me was a totally rusted out old chassis from a 1930s car, no wheels, no steering wheel, no seats, sitting on a tow truck with a price tag of $2,000. Imagine getting it home and beginning the task of converting it into an exact copy of its original designation! Imagine the bits and pieces required to make the thing whole again, pieces that must have to be bought from these small-time guys running their own businesses, each one specializing in a particular part, this one the number plates, this one the carburetor parts, this one the piece that ran along the outside of the car joining the axels to the engine pistons, and so on ad infinitum.  There were lines and lines, tables groaning under old licence plates, dating right back to the first plate ever issued in Texas in 1917, now up for sale for $550 each.  I even noticed some authentic 1932 equipment, listed as “brand new”, the part having been manufactured recently. Wow! I really do find it tough to get into the minds of these sellers and buyers,  prostate before their immense hobby.
Well, it takes all kinds to make our world. The whole exhibition was lined with food stalls, dozens and dozens of them, not unexpectedly purveying what is customarily called junk food --- chips, burgers, beer ---the impact of which seemed to be clear from the immense pounds of wobbling flesh being carried around.
Well, we are far from immune to that Canada, either. But maybe we carry it off with less bravado than the Texans. Which is, I suppose, what makes them unusual and noteworthy on this continent.


Tuesday, April 5, 2016

Thomas Piketty

Yanis Varoufakis

Link of the Day: April 5 2016:  Here is a link to a review of two books, one by French leftist economist Thomas Piketty, the other by Greek leftist economist Yanis Varoufakis, which each posit a way to a united, democratic Europe that, the reviewer (from The Guardian, London) says, offers a correct analysis of the situation, that is never likely to be adopted. More’s the pity, one might say, if, like me, you view the world from a leftist perspective, and are alarmed by the right-wing, neo-Nazi or fascistic movements becoming popular throughout Europe. Read the review, by Paul Mason, here.