Sunday, August 13, 2017

My Log 555 August 11 2017: Nuclear power: the force that could destroy our world, and that already has come within a whisker of doing so

I heard some commentators on television the other day say that for human beings to maintain nuclear weapons is equivalent to leaving a loaded shotgun in a kindergarten.
I thought when I heard it that it is a totally apt comparison, but it seems even more appropriate since the extraordinary statement by the nuclear-warrior-number-one, the United States president, that he is ready to load on to North Korea fire and fury “such as the world has ever seen before.” This can mean only one thing: nuclear war.
It happens I had been thinking about this recently, after having viewed an extraordinary film called Command and Control, made by PBS, the American TV channel, about a nuclear accident that occurred in Arkansas in 1980.This film confirmed all the doubts I have carried with me through my entire life about nuclear power, and (let me get this off my chest right here) this is a film that I believe every person in the world should see, and that should be required viewing in every high school on earth. It lasts for 91 minutes, was issued in 2012, and was directed by Robert Kenner.
I remember most clearly  putting pen to paper to oppose nuclear power when I had briefly returned to New Zealand to live in the 1970s. Before that, I remember in 1950 in Montreal covering a luncheon address by the man in charge of nuclear research in Canada, who airily dismissed all objections based on the lack of control of the waste products, by uttering the infamous lie, that they had the waste disposal problem totally  under control.  Of course, it is so far from being under control, that they still have no idea how to dispose safely of the waste products, and it is known that leaks are occurring in many places from these supposedly safe storage places.
I 1975 I wrote an impassioned article opposing the proposal of the New Zealand government of the day to build a nuclear power station at the foot of one of the two harbours around whose shores is built the city of Auckland, with a quarter of the nation’s population. Of course, in response to my article the pro-nuclear people trotted out all their comforting bromides, but in the end the proposal was defeated by a combination of pressures brought by environmentalists in alliance with the indigenous Maori people, whose first objection was the simple but convincing fear that the power station would invade and ruin the bed of the shell fish they had always --- and in this case “always” means, for many, many centuries --- depended on.  New Zealand is still free of nuclear power to this day, and is still refusing to admit into its ports American warships carrying nuclear power, a policy that is so popular that it has even survived a series of conservative governments.
However, back to this film which reveals, in its last moments  after a  harrowing hour-and-a-half in which it describes the horrors of a nuclear accident, that thousands --- I’ll repeat that, thousands --- of such accidents have occurred in the more than half a century that nuclear power and the weapon systems it has spawned have been bestriding the world.
The accident occurred to a Titan II, an immense underground missile that was armed with the most powerful of all  hydrogen bombs, said to contain three times more explosive power than all the bombs used by all nations of both sides during World War II, including the two atomic bombs dropped on Japan, and all this power was aimed at the Soviet Union. One of the men interviewed in the film said it was assumed in the early days of nuclear weapons, that it would take between 50 and 200 nuclear bombs to completely annihilate the Soviet Union, which apparently was the objective of the system, but by the mid-1960s, the US had 32,000 of them and for those working on building them the “money was free”. They had bombers carrying nuclear bombs in the air at all times, and submarines around the world were armed with bombs ready to be fired at a moment’s notice.  One of the former workers in the maintenance system says in the film that whenever he entered the missile silo, his team was in charge of it, and they had to be ready to discharge the missile on notice. He said, “I had no problem with that, even though I would be killing ten million people in seconds, I would never have hesitated.” It was being done in defence of his country, he argued, it was a deterrent, and to be convincing, “we had to show that we were ready to use it.”
I pause here to remark that merely to describe this programme must surely indicate to any sane person that the world has gone mad, and that especially lunatic are the persons who have undertaken to carry out these functions.   One thing I have noticed throughout my life is that no matter how horrendous the ideas of certain leaders may be --- think Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Idi Amin, Emperor for Life Bokassa in the murderous Central African Republic, as well as a succession of American presidents (as well, I suppose, as the leaders of the Soviet Union, France, the United Kingdom) and there are plenty of others who could be cited --- these leaders always find people willing to carry out their orders.
The accident was caused by the simplest little thing: one of the maintenance teams that were constantly working to keep the missile in  order was advised at the end of their shift of some trouble with the pressure in the oxidizer tank,  which contained one of the two elements needed to fire the missile, the other being kept in an interlocking fuel tank. One member of the team who was interviewed said that before they entered the silo to examine this routine problem he had forgotten to take a torque wrench from his truck. He was not worried because this was a recent change in procedure: “I had spent three years using a ratchet, so instead of sending someone back to get the wrench, I grabbed the ratchet.” Of such small human errors are accidents caused. Using the ratchet, three feet long, with which he was completely familiar, when his hand slipped, a small but solid eight-pound metal socket attached to the ratchet fell and went hurtling down the seventy foot length of the several-stories-high missile, landed on the side of the fuel tank, making a small hole in it, and allowing a stream of fuel to eject.  The fuel system required that the oxidizer and fuel be mixed to create the explosion that would launch the missile, and the worker was aware that they could not stop what was happening.
The rest of the film is a detailed account of the efforts made to save the missile from exploding, because the nuclear weapon already armed on the head of the missile was of such force that it could possibly have devastated almost the whole of the eastern seaboard of the US including doing grave damage to most of its big cities, and killing, certainly, hundreds of thousands of people.
The film describes an accident that occurred in North Carolina in 1961 when a B52 bomber carrying two hydrogen bombs broke up, and the two bombs were released. One of them on hitting the ground went through all its arming steps and a firing signal was sent, and the only thing that prevented a four megaton explosion was a single switch, just like a light switch on the living room wall.  “If the right two wires had touched,” explains one worker in the system, “the bomb would have detonated, period.” At that time the number of nuclear accidents was increasing, and the same man said, “I read through all the known accident reports, and it scared the hell out of me.” They were shocked     when they realized the weapons they had always said were safe were not nearly as safe as had been assumed. They now realized that thousands of American nuclear weapons were vulnerable in case of accident, including the biggest one of all, the very one sitting on top of the Titan II missile in Arkansas.
The alarm went off at 6.35 pm, and it took some hours before effective action could be organized to deal with the problem. Indeed, the story appears to be one of mistaken orders, mostly given by people higher up in the chain of command who were not that familiar with the circumstances of the maintenance teams on the ground. At one point the only man in the team who seemed to have a practical idea of what to do was ordered not to go into the silo. An early mistake was to abandon the control room, so that they did not have available to them only way of dealing with the problem. Eventually they had to go back in, but by that time it was too late, and at least one of the team was incinerated when eventually the missile site exploded with a monstrous roar.
It seems that the warhead was not ignited, but instead was blown off its place at the head of the missile to land more or less harmlessly outside the site. But the entire missile site was destroyed by the explosion and fire that followed.
This film is the most graphic I have seen demonstrating the dangers of nuclear power, but it is a wonder that we need to be reminded of these dangers. The Chernobyl disaster in Ukraine in 1986 sent its effects over all of Western Europe, and it was just a simple nuclear power generating station. More recently the Fukushima plant in Japan, carelessly sited in the path of a tsunami following a huge nearby undersea earthquake, is still, six years after the event, apparently still forty years from being normalized. I remember years ago passing by the Three Mile station in Pennsylvania that had a meltdown in 1979, which brought a sort of freeze to all future nuclear projects in the United States.  All the bromides delivered by the nuclear apologists pale into insignificance beside the massive record of nuclear accidents, more than 100 in eleven countries according to the latest Wikipedia count. And they, of course, exclude the “thousands” that were admitted to in this film in relation to weapons systems.
We just can’t believe in nuclear power as one of the elements for beating our climate change problem. The sooner we shut down every nuclear power station, the safer we will be.




Saturday, August 5, 2017

My Log 554 August 5 2017: My confession: I have always loved sports, and --- though it is getting tougher all the time, since money took over --- this is my rationale for doing so.

Among that circle of people in Canada whom I would call my friends, I have always known that I am regarded as rather peculiar because of my fondness for sport. I tell them, I’m sorry, I know that what you say --- that sport is the opiate of the masses, an important component of the bread and circuses by which the ruling elite, the governing wealth-owners, keep the populace diverted  --- is quite true. But the fact is I have been interested in sport ever since I was a kid, and until I stopped buying newspapers a few years ago, the sports pages were always the first I read.
Pathetic, I know, but it is an ingrained habit, and I feel I have good reason for it. I grew up in a country, New Zealand, in which it was customary for all children --- or almost all --- to play games, and play them on the amazingly extensive playing grounds provided for the purpose. The two primary --- known here as elementary --- schools I attended had playing grounds big enough for two football fields. And when I went to high school we not only had a field large enough for three or four football grounds in the winter, and for several cricket pitches and a running track in the summer, in addition to an outdoor fives court, but every Wednesday afternoon was set aside not for classroom learning, but for playing games, in addition to our regular classes in the gym as part of the learning curriculum. I took to playing rugby, cricket, tennis, running and jumping even before I hit high school, and once there my dearest wish every morning was to get to school as early as possible so I could get be sure of getting in up to an hour playing fives against all-comers before the 9 am whistle blew for assembly.
This was the sport of which I grew to be so fond. And I was still in my early teens when my weekends were occupied with cricket matches played against local teams in a junior league, and Rugby against similarly matched outsiders of appropriate size.  In both of these we played against the local Borstal, with its preponderance of young Maori inmates who scared the bejesus out of us with their pre-game hakas --- a useful element in our education about the realities of our society.
In my spare time I spent many hours at the local tennis courts, where our presence was accepted without any suggestion we must pay, and we were even allowed to sneak on to the local golf course so long as we did not interrupt the games of the adults --- once again, without any whiff of money entering the matter. In fact, I still find I odd, the very idea that one has to pay for exercise.
I turned out to be pretty good at most of these games, and I can honestly admit that until I was about nineteen or so these sports were what occupied most of my mind most of the time. I felt like I had read almost every book written on cricket, which has a very rich literature, let me assure you, and I could recite the scores of titanic Test matches between Australia and England for years back. I remember on one occasion being taken by my Dad to see an All Blacks Rugby match, and murmuring to him, I would die to be an All Black.” (The All Blacks, for those who do not know, are the representative Rugby team of New Zealand, a team which, among all the world’s games, still has the highest percentage of winning games of any team in the world.) As a kid I had pictures on my bedroom wall of every All Black team from 1905 up to 1937.
This, of course was not sport as it is known now. Even at international level, the teams were all amateur in those days: the All Blacks would undertake a six month tour of Britain and France, and the players would get a few dollars a day as an allowance. Their jobs would be held open for them by sympathetic employers.  I remember the greatest cricket batsman of all time, Don Bradman, of Australia,  telling of how he would go into his office to do a couple of hours’ work before getting to the cricket ground in time for the 11 pm start of a Test match on whose outcome the entire nation might be hanging.
In our own small city of 26,000, my older brothers played on club teams with guys who had been chosen for the All Blacks: they were not only national figures, but our local heroes, who went to the Saturday night dances with my brothers and their girl friends.
I had to give up playing all these games when I quit high school after four years, and got a job in the local newspaper, where I had to be available to  collect the results of the myriad of games played across the city every Saturday. I wrote about sports, too. Of course in our day we never thought of interviewing the players. They were never on that kind of pedestal: after all, they were just guys from around the road who played the games for love of them. 
I left that country when I was 22. I went back after 25 years with four children, some of whom settled down into the sporting life described above. I didn't stay long, a mere eighteen months, having discovered that not only had I changed, but so had the country, and we were no longer a perfect fit.  But since then I have the strong impression that the eighteen months they spent in New Zealand were among he happiest my children have ever known. They revelled in the relaxed atmosphere of the schools, which still seemed dedicated to developing them both in their intellects and in their bodies.
And when one of my sons accompanied me back on a holiday 30 years later, and we stayed briefly with my brother in a small country town in the North Island, we had occasion to see the sports system, the all-inclusive sports system which makes room for everyone who wants to play a game, still operating at full bore throughout the country. In my day there was no such thing as “not making the team”: they would make as many teams as were needed.  My brother’s daughter was a pre-teen, but she was a member of a netball team that took part in a regular Saturday morning event in which teams from many schools were engaged, an event  in which the two races, Maori and pakehas were mixed as if there were no difference between them, and in which those adults directing the event and managing it were also racially mixed just as were the players.
This is why I have always loved sports. Even today, when the sport that comes to us through our electronic connections is totally controlled by money, and is in so many ways despicable, nevertheless, in spite of everything, the contests between the players themselves are usually genuine, and worth watching. (Dull would he be of soul, as Wordsworth might have remarked, who could not be stirred by the spectacle of Roger Federer in full flight winning his eighth Wimbledon title last month.)
What has sparked this piece is that I have just sat all day watching first, a Rugby game played in South Africa, and secondly, an international athletics meet held in London, England. Both have been richly rewarding, in my opinion (though I am ready to concede the argument that they may operate as opiates in my life.) The first was the final match in a long tournament known as the Super 15 in which top teams from New Zealand, Australia, South Africa, Argentina and Japan compete. The New Zealand teams usually fall afoul of the 1700 metres elevation of Johannesberg, especially in the high-pressure of a big final. But on this occasion they held tough, and won narrowly.  Rugby was the last major sport to go professional, but they have managed to retain some nice touches, especially one by which the losing team of an international lines up to applaud the victors as they pass between them off the field. The winning New Zealand coach at the last World Cup kept reminding his team and their supporters that, after all, it was only a game, they were playing a game, and that was not an important matter in the affairs of the world.  
In London it was the last race of Usain Bolt, one of the most extraordinary athletes ever to have graced any sport. Until his arrival on the scene, the world of big-time sprinting was dominated by a pack of snarling, bad-mannered and unsportsmanlike American runners, who were totally disarmed by this smiling jokester, talking away to them before the race, joking and striking silly poses, and then finally demolishing them all by running faster --- very much faster --- than anyone has ever run in the history of running.
In this his last race, there was an enormous amount of hype, which Bolt good-humoredly played along with: he said he would retire undefeated, unvanquished. but in the event, he managed, for the first time in his career of important races, only third.  It didn’t seem to diminish his spirit in any way: he hugged and celebrated the winners, and laughed and joked his way around the track as he said farewell to the sport and the crowds who like me, have adored him.
Like most opiates, I guess, this one can make you feel awfully good at times.    




Tuesday, July 18, 2017

My Log 553 July 18 2017: Some reflections on unions and bosses: Closed shop, union shop, non-union shop, I have experienced them all. Even “Canada shop”

IN my last blog I touched on the dilemma of the working man in face of the decline in unions. It may seem puzzling as to why unions, the very bedrock of the advancement of the condition of working people, should have declined.
Where I grew to adulthood, in New Zealand, the Labour government of 1935-49 had passed legislation making it compulsory for anyone who had a job to join a union. Thus, when I left school to work in the local newspaper, I joined the New Zealand Journalists’ Union, and was covered by the provisions of the nationally-negotiated contract covering all newspapers in New Zealand.
I grew up to be proud of this union membership, even though, with hindsight, it could be argued that such a system did lead to the creation of some unions that were, as the saying goes, deadwood, whose executives were not really imbued with the principles of unionism, and were inactive in the defence of the rights of their members.
At the time the politics of the general society in which the Cold War was settling in, interfered with the running of unions to a certain extent. In the antipodes, in particular, as on the West Coast of the United States, the wharfies, as they were called, workers on the nation’s wharves, tended to be led by members of the Communist party, which at the time, though small in number were large in influence, because of their concentration on the welfare of working people, especially in the unions. There, as in Canada, which had is own Communist-led Canadian Seamen’s Union (CSU), the leaders of the more orthodox union collectives were firmly set against the Communist unions, and since it was mainly the Communist-led unions that caused industrial strife, such collectives --- the AFL-CIO in the United States, for example, the Federation of Labour in New Zealand, the Canadian Labour Congress in Canada ---- gradually began to act more or less in lockstep with their governments. My sympathies at the time were with the more militant unions, which not only were strong in defence of their members, but also had no hesitation in using their influence in support of foreign workers. For example, it was not at all unusual for the Australian wharfies to refuse to handle ships for political reasons, such as in support of  anti-imperialist struggles being fought in various parts of the world, and I firmly supported these actions.  With the enthusiastic backing of the media, governments were easily able to portray these actions as being stimulated by Communist affiliations with the Soviet Union.
It is undeniable, of course,  that western Communist parties lost all hope they may have had of broad public support when  they first opposed the  Second World War because of the pact between the Soviet Union and the Germans, and then, when Germany attacked Russia in 1941, they changed their minds on a dime, and became effective fighters against the Nazis.
Thus, immediately after the war, it was easy for non-Communist Western governments to use the Communist stick to beat the trades unions with, and they didn't hesitate to do it.  In the United States unions became tainted with corruption and gangsterism, but this was not enough for the employers, who frankly set out to denigrate unions and used every  trick in the book to undermine them.  Years later I worked on finishing a small film made at the NFB called Who Needs Unions? which followed the career of a man whose business it was to propagate the anti-union case, something he and others of his ilk did with sensational success.
When I left New Zealand in 1950, and a year later was hoping to get a job in England, I ran into the problem of jurisdictions that was altogether avoided in New Zealand by its system of mandatory unionism. Many English unions were what was known as “closed shops.” That is, you could only join them by getting a job; but to get a job you needed to be a union member. Some were simply “union shops”, that is, once you got a job, you had to join the union. And then, of course, there were jobs that were non-unionized. Although I eventually succeeded in getting a job for a small weekly in Coventry,Warwickshire, I really cannot remember that I was ever required to join the union, although I am fairly sure the journalists on  the local evening newspaper --- which owned the little weekly for which I worked --- were union members.
It was not until I came to Canada in 1954 that I ran into the non-union shop, and that with a vengeance.  My first port of call was Toronto, where I was told I needed Canadian experience to be hired by a Canadian newspaper --- if one were to describe this in the jurisdictional terms outlined above, I suppose this could be called the “Canadian shop” or the Canadian version of the English “union shop”  --- “you can get Canadian experience only by working in a Canadian newspaper, but to get a job in a Canadian newspaper, you need Canadian experience.”
When I was hired to work on the Northern Daily News in Kirkland Lake, I ran into the Thomson newspaper chain, Roy Thomson’s infamous creation, a chain of small-town newspapers built on the firm principle of paying the lowest wages possible consistent with keeping unions at bay.  Here I discovered an entirely new instrument in my experience, an electronic tape that could be attached to a linotype machine and do the work that hitherto had been done by a linotype operator. The sole purpose of this was to avoid hiring the skilled staffers who were always the most likely to be unionized.  The tape was sent out from headquarters in Toronto, containing news dispatches from around the country and the world, and even editorials, pre-written in Toronto. The editorial staff was run by two members, an editor and chief sub-editor (a recovering drunk, who was down on his luck from a ruined career in the metropolitan centres) who might be considered full-time workers, while the reporting staff was made up of people like myself, experienced journalists, most of us, from England (a descendant of the poet Wordsworth), South Africa,  Jamaica, Latvia and New Zealand who had drifted into the country from abroad, and were willing to accept whatever wage was offered. We were expected to work at any time of the day or night, any day of the week, and whatever we wrote was set in type by the sole linotype operator needed to keep the system moving.
Although two of us on that staff later received the Order of Canada (Fred Bruemmer, later a famed Arctic photographer and myself), the newspaper that resulted from our efforts was a poor thing, indeed as were all of the other newspapers in Thomson’s chain. Roy Thomson had been an itinerant businessman whose efforts to get going all proved fruitless until he tried to sell radios in Northern Ontario, and decided to set up a radio station to encourage sales. This had caught on until he was able to buy his first small local newspaper in Timmins, and the rest is history. Thomson Newspapers became one of the mightiest businesses in the entire world of journalism, operating in several countries, and buying the man himself a peerage in the British realm. His first quality newspaper, as they are called, was the well-regarded and long-established  Scotsman.  Next he was able to establish the first Scottish TV station, which, he said, in a famous quote, was “like a permit to print money.”
I lasted only three months on the $45 a week he paid me, and soon moved on to the Winnipeg Free Press, another low-paying non-union paper but one with a solid reputation that rested on the fact that its editor for more than 40 years, J.W. Dafoe, had such political influence that his turgid editorials were said to be capable of toppling governments. I used to whisper in the editorial room that the newspaper was “regarded as a great newspaper by more people who had never read it, than any other in history.”
When I moved on after two years to Montreal, I found myself in a very strange newspaper situation. This was 1957, and although the tranquil revolution had not yet arrived, French-language journalists had managed to get themselves unionized. Through a stroke of good fortune I became friendly with many of them and they introduced me to a side of Quebec life ---modern, radical, anti-clerical, pro-union and alive to the outside world --- which seemed to be unknown to those running the English-language newspaper for which I worked.  On our side of the town, we were employed by a steadfastly anti-union boss, who nevertheless had sense enough to peg his wage structure at just below the higher wages won by the French journalists through their union.
I remember after I had been there a couple of years, someone arrived from the American Newspaper Guild in the United States who had the intention of perhaps organizing Montreal’s English-language journalists. He asked me what sort of support he could expect from the journalists on our staff, so one evening I ran through the list of some 130 editorial staffers with him, and came up with four whom I considered might be relied upon in a union organizing drive. He went away.
In fact, the behaviour of the French journalists at that time was a revelation to me. While we were mere creatures of the editors and management, without any leverage to control our work, the French journalists were extremely active at the level or professionalism, and did not hesitate to strike when they felt they had good cause.  On one strike at La Presse they had not been content just with picketing, but had managed to produce every day a miniature version of the newspaper which they called La Presse Ouvriere that became a considerable weapon in their armoury. That strike ended with the overthrow of the administration of the newspaper and its replacement with a new editor, with some of the more vigorous and radical younger journalists promoted to management positions. A result like this could not even be dreamed of on the English-language side.
I had never been impressed with the management of The Montreal Star, an immensely profitable newspaper that continued rolling on thanks to its guaranteed huge classified advertising every day. After I left the newspaper the proprietorial McConnell family wanted money more than they wanted a newspaper, and sold the paper to a chain organized by the Winnipeg Free Press. They were  finally unionized in the 1970s. But on neither side did they have experience of negotiating, and when in 1979 negotiations seized to a halt with a strike, the conflict was allowed --- in my view through stupid management --- to drag on for so long that when the strike was settled the newspaper had lost its formerly unchallenged circulation.
So, a deal --- a dirty deal, if I may coin a phrase --- was made between the Free Press outfit and the Southam’s chain that owned The Gazette, the only remaining English-language newspaper.  The Southam paper in Winnipeg would be closed, leaving the field to the Free Press,  and simultaneously the Star in Montreal would also be closed leaving the field to the Gazette.
I suppose these are the kinds of deals one has to expect from capitalism, where money and profits are the only criteria of success. But since I returned to Montreal I have mentioned from time to time that I had worked on The Montreal Star and have been surprised at an almost unanimous reaction: oh yes, the Star was such a good newspaper, we miss the Star, we read the Star every day.
I am not sure the Star ever deserved such accolades. But certainly its loss has been an immense one to Montreal as a city, much greater than those of us who wrote for it could ever have imagined in the years leading up to the tranquil revolution.