Monday, July 17, 2017

My Log 552 July 14 2017: Mea culpa: I confess to rigidity in my beliefs, but that conceded, can find no reason to change

For a guy like me, who hates flags, the revamped version of Sherbrooke street in downtown Montreal should be a nightmare. Probably as part of the 375th anniversary of the founding of the city, this street, once known as the most elegant in the country, has been given an almost total makeover.  Ancient pipes, sewers and wires have been replaced (as in many other parts of the city), and spiffing new sidewalks have been constructed, twice as wide as they used to be, beautifully paved with handsome stones, and with lovely new trees, already flowering though just planted, and beautiful flower boxes along the one kilometer of roadway between the intersections with St Laurent boulevard in the east, and Guy street in the west. To mark the occasion some 30 artworks have been commissioned and laid out along the way, and all in all one might be excused for thinking it is a job well done.
Except for this one thing: the street has been decorated with the flags of surely all of the world’s nation states, and to accommodate them, a series of long high aluminum poles have been established on heavy concrete bases that are themselves far from beautiful, poles that reach up towards the sky and tend to give the street an overladen sort of feel.
But I have to confess, much as I dislike flags, that all those multi-coloured flags do enliven what has become in the last half century  a more or less typically North American-looking street of gleaming skyscrapers, many of whose ground floors are now occupied with pizza and burger joints. I myself first saw the street more than 60 years ago, when it was still marked with the elegant ancient houses of Montreal’s earlier times, and over the years I have been one with the citizens who have deplored every demolition of these old houses and their replacement with skyscrapers that have reduced the city’s links with its past. 
In those days Sherbrooke was more or less a symbol of the primacy of the monied class that had played so prominent a role in the development of Canada, just as its twin street, Ste. Catherine,  that runs parallel through the city 200 or 300 yards to the south seemed to be, in its brawling, bustling, vulgar antithesis, the street of the common man. At the time, I remember, Ste. Catherine was loftily but rather affectionately described by the well-known British architectural critic Reyner Banham as “one of the great, awful streets of the world.” Unfortunately in recent decades Sherbrooke has moved in the direction of Ste. Catherine as it has become just another street of commerce, and all the prettying up that  has recently been undertaken, though welcome, seems unlikely to arrest its movement towards aesthetic mediocrity.
It was a bit of a shock to me today to see how the flags have enlivened the Sherbrooke street scene, because ever since I was a kid in New Zealand and refused to stand up for the national anthem when it was played before the movies, I have distrusted everything to do with flags, and I cannot imagine myself ever carrying one and waving it around to establish the supremacy of our particular nation, whichever that might be. In fact some years ago I gave evidence to a parliamentary committee on citizenship and told its members that two of the things I liked particularly about Canada when I first came here in 1954 were that the nation had no flag, and no anthem.  (A third element I mentioned was that the only thing  that seemed to be demanded of a new resident of Canada was that he go into debt enough to buy a second-hand car. Ah, those were the days!)
Ruminating on my detestation of flags, I began to think that maybe I have taken it a bit too far.  Nearing the end of my ninth decade, I have surely reached the time when I might justifiably engage in some self-criticism (as the Communists used to call it.)
There might even be other things for which I might justifiably be criticized.
For example, I have never voted either Liberal or Conservative, and have always been so fixed in my detestation for our governing parties as to vow that I never would vote for either of them. I suppose it can be argued that occasionally some Liberal Members of Parliament might be decent fellows deserving of support. Okay, I am willing to concede that, although I cannot reasonably extend my concession to cover Conservatives.  All of this stems from my upbringing in a country that was ruled by a Labour government in my youth.  I always heartily supported that party, and grew to detest the Conservative  opposition, and I have carried that on through my seven or eight decades since, having never seen any reason to change my opinion. When I came to Canada I quickly realized that one of the things separating this country from the United States was simply the existence of the NDP (or CCF, as it was known when I arrived), because it has kept as part of the normal political discourse in this country ideas of collective responsibility that are regarded as anathema in the United States. This difference was illustrated to me forcefully when I first visited the United States in 1956, and met many people of like mind to mine who were living in isolation from neighbours who shunned them because of their ideas. As I heard Noam Chomsky say in a recent interview, solidarity is the word that describes the idea that we are all responsible for each other, the very bedrock idea of national health systems, social welfare schemes and so on. I agreed entirely with his description of how without this quality no society can solve its social problems over the long term. The proof of this is in the current situation of United States and British society, no longer functioning as democracies but as oligarchies governed by wealth-owners, whose wealth in recent years has grown to obscene levels.
I read just today that this rise in inequality has gone in lockstep with the decline in union membership.  In the days when union membership in the United States was 30 per cent of non-public workers, the difference between the income of the highest paid CEO and the average worker was as 30 to 1. Now, with union membership fallen to 6.5 per cent, the difference is as 350 to 1. In that same article I read of the multitude of measures enacted to destroy the Labour movement. In fact, according to the International Labor Organization, the United States is violating international standards by failing to protect the right to organize, by banning secondary strikes and boycotts, and by allowing employers to permanently replace workers who strike. If strikes are banned, workers are defenceless against their employers, and, as the authors contend, all advancement in the rights of workers have been won as a result of strikes, which means that they are in the present circumstances unable to organize workers effectively into unions for collective action. (This information is taken from an article in the Boston Review called The Right to Strike, by James Gray Pope, Ed Bruno and Peter Kellman.)
I didn’t intend when I set out to write this to descend into a defence of my opinions in this way. Rather, I was expecting to confess to a certain rigidity of opinion.
Another area in which I am even more rigid now than when I was younger is in my attitude towards religion. I cannot deny that there have been good people who have been motivated by religion and have done wonderful works. But my study of the history of how indigenous people have been treated by the invaders who have taken over their lands has hardened my detestation of those who came among them propagating what they claimed were superior religions.  It is undeniable that missionaries have been part of the conquering force, in fact, in many places they have been precursors of the soldiers who have followed them with their guns. And, taken all in all, I find that the effects of religion have been disastrous to human kind in general. It is impossible to believe that reasonable people can actually believe many of the central precepts of religions. We have been seeing in recent years the rise of the suicide bomber who is apparently motivated by the belief that his  or her action will result in his being transported to a heaven in which he will have access to 72 virgins. I daren’t go on with a catalogue of the absurdities that are believed by religious adherents, but will content myself with mentioning the supposedly virgin birth of the leading figure in a religion whose name discretion forbids me to mention.
Anyway, if any of my acquaintances (or readers) find me too rigid in expression or belief, I have written this to say that (maybe) I agree with them. I accept I could be wrong, but please don't expect me to vote Liberal or Conservative in the next election.






Tuesday, July 4, 2017

My Log 551 July 4 2017: At last, some justice for Omar Khadr, who at 15 was almost killed in an Afghanistan firefight, and was treated as a guilty soldier by both American and Canadian governments

It is probably in the nature of being a journalist that one tends to concentrate on things that need to be improved or changed, but I can hardly think of a single government action that has given me more pleasure than today’s news that the government of Canada intends to apologize to Omar Khadr, and compensate him for the terrible experiences he has undergone, at least partly because (as the Supreme Court has found) of actions of this government’s officers.
This young man has never had a break in life: the son of a fanatic follower of Al Queda, he was transported at the age of 15 by his father  into the heart of the  battles undertaken by the Western world against Afghanistan, which was thought to harbour Osama Bin Laden, held responsible for the attack by Saudi terrorists on the World Trade Centre in New York. Although only a child, he was present during a firefight in which everyone except him and one or two others were killed.  American soldiers believed --- or at least said they believed --- that he had thrown a grenade that had killed an American soldier, but Khadr was discovered covered in blood, one eye permanently damaged, and  having been shot twice in the chest.  When arrested by the Americans, he was treated thereafter as an adult, in violation of all the rules of war, and after a period in Bagram air base prison, during which he claims to have been tortured and roughly handled by his interrogators, he was transferred to Guantanamo, where he became the youngest inmate.
Khadr  owes his escape from that dreadful prison to the selfless Edmonton lawyer, Dennis Edney, who represented him throughout his 10 year imprisonment in the Cuban prison and later, after he was  reluctantly transferred to Canada because the Canadian courts put the onus on the Harper government to facilitate his return to his home country. The government showed no enthusiasm for this task, and even after his arrival home, they made his life as difficult as possible.
That he was by this time as young man of 25 did not alter the fact that he had been a child when arrested, but neither the American nor the Canadian governments took this into account in deciding on his punishment.
Very severe doubt was thrown on the American claim that he threw a grenade that killed an American soldier, but Edney advised him to accept a plea deal, confessing to the crime to escape the most probable outcome of the Guantanamo legal proceedings, which would have been a 40-year prison term, in return for a reduced sentence of eight years to be served out in Canadian prisons.
Eventually, again at he insistence of Canadian courts, he was released from prison, into the custody of his lawyer, who has  sheltered him in his Edmonton home ever since.
That he is now to be granted compensation for his ordeal is no more than he deserves, for he has accepted the misfortunes that have followed him through life with remarkable courage and grace.




Sunday, July 2, 2017

My Log 550 July 1 2017:Some renewed interest in how our Canadian cities are being developed: maybe too late to save us from the worst disasters arising from the capitalist ethos

I’ve noticed in the Canadian press a recent outbreak of articles about the Canadian future, possibly stimulated by the 150th birthday celebrations. It is always to be welcomed when people pay attention to the underlying trends of our urban developments, which still often go more or less unregarded, as if there were something rather improper about criticizing the ethics and operations of capitalism.  But perhaps as someone who was writing about these things half a century ago, I may be permitted to remark that we still seem to be wrestling with the same problems as we were in the late 1960s.
My first essay into dealing with urban problems came in the late 1950s when I was assigned to write a series for The Montreal Star about the city’s burgeoning western suburbs --- Point Claire, Dorval, Beaconsfield and so on, when I began to spot the problems that might follow the buying and selling of privately held land, as if it were simply a commodity like any other, the major one being the constant escalation in land and house prices to the point that today in at least two Canadian cities, it is now impossible for any ordinary wage-earner to buy a property.
I was then sent as a correspondent to London, England, and that gave me an opportunity to look at the somewhat absurd British system of land ownership. In the cities it was marked by a strange system of leaseholds, the 99-year lease being perhaps the most popular, a lease that could be sub-leased any number of times, each time giving rise to an entirely unofficial payment known as “key money” which became more of a burden than the cost of the lease itself.  The rural ownership situation was still frankly bordering on the feudal. Vast land-owning estates held by the rural aristocracy meant that most farms were worked by tenant farmers. Before ever coming to Canada I had worked in Britain for a small Midlands weekly newspaper, for which I wrote a weekly column featuring local farmers, and I had discovered there was still an air of touching the forelock before the master-class, at least from my class-free Antipodean point of view.
In the 1960s I had the chance to examine how they handled things in Scandinavia, and I began to realize how much social change depends upon support from an educated electorate. One nugget that stuck with me was that in 1923, a Conservative city government in Stockholm bought all the urban land on which, twenty or thirty years later, the nation’s socialist governments were able to build the impressive satellite cities that nowadays ring the beautiful capital city. This of course, was just one item in a national programme of dovetailed policies that could be described as social democratic. They made a significant effort to maintain house prices and rents at a level that was affordable, using a complex formula that one would need to be a skilled mathematician to understand properly. They adopted measures designed to take the curse off the idea of public housing, which is such a significant part of the Canadian and American urban ethos. In Sweden, having built thousands of apartments, they rented them to tenants, some of whom were subsidized because of their lower incomes, and some of whom were not. Since no one could be sure whether their neighbours were among those being subsidized, the entire housing complex never was tabbed as public housing with all the disadvantages associated with that expression on this side of the Atlantic, with its history of building “the projects” that seem almost from the first to be destined to become urban slums.
In Sweden also, they had a traditional concept called “Everyman’s right” under which any person could legally approach any piece of land or structure to within a specified distance, on condition that they behaved themselves according to a widely accepted code of ethics.   I struck something similar in Britain, where one traditional way in which lands were made accessible to the public was through use. In other words, if there was a piece of land --- the Inns of Court in London are an example --- that had been open to the public for generations,  it was thereby declared to be land of public access. Britain was, and I presume still is, criss-crossed by a system of walking paths established across what would otherwise be private holdings, but that are recognized as paths open without question to public use. In that way, too, the great parks of central London, which were originally Royal holdings, fell open to public use because the public had always used them. (In Ottawa when Governor-general Jeanne Sauve closed her residence to the public, I argued that we had the right to use it because we had been doing so since before Canada was a nation, playing cricket thereon. I said her action was the most reactionary government action in relation to open space since Henry VIII.)
In opposition to this, of course was the contrary method in which private landowners, among whom were the vast estates of various nobility, would build a square of graceful identical housing around an area of open land that in the 1960s was still, in many places, restricted for the use of the tenants in the surrounding buildings. When the Labour government was elected in 1945 it made strenuous efforts to open these squares to the general public: some of these efforts succeeded --- for example, in the case of Grosvenor Square, where the Canadian  and American governments maintained important offices ---  whereas in other squares ---  for example, Eaton Square in Mayfair ---- the conservative local governments fought bitterly to maintain these squares as areas of privilege.
Even in European countries that were not practising democratic socialism, such as Holland, the idea of meticulous planning had caught on, because that county is one of the most heavily populated in the world, and unless it was to become a sea of unrelieved horrors, strict measures had to be taken to keep development under control. I remember once when visiting a government official he took me over to his window on the fifth floor of his building, and pointed out to me that we could see five separate cities from where we stood. Each was separated from the others by an area of open space. The North American disease of urban sprawl was not permitted, and there were no such streets as one could find on the south shore from Montreal, a landscape of horrendous unaesthetic disaster, strewn with  advertisements, garish lighting and building that seems never to have been subject to any sort of public control.
When I returned  to Montreal in 1968 I began to write about Canada’s urban problems, examining the planning background of most of our major cities. I found to my surprise that in the early 1960s little connection existed between the various cities, which were each pursuing very different courses towards their expansion.  At one point I gathered my newspaper articles into a book, hoping it would be of interest to anyone who cared about the quality of his or her city.  I espoused in that book something like the Swedish system of public ownership of urban land.
In fact, I arrived back almost simultaneously with the coming to power of Pierre Elliot Trudeau, who, during the 11 years of his first administration introduced many innovative programmes such as had never been seen in Canadian politics before. Programmes like the Local Initiatives Programme, under which anyone with a good idea could apply for a grant to carry it to fruition, giving rise to many excellent works across the country, most of them unspectacular in size, but significant in improving the quality of life in our communities; like the Company of Young Canadians, which, as the name suggests,  hired young Canadians to fan out throughout the country, to make connections with people whose lives needed  improvements they could not afford, and to support them in efforts to improve their quality of life in this way; programmes like the Urban Affairs Ministry, a very interesting development that fell unfortunately between established ministries, and ran afoul of  existing jurisdictions; programmes like Kitimavik,  which was open to usually aimless youth who were gathered into groups under a  discipline of a kind they had never known, and were set to work to improve not only their own  perceptions of the meaning of life but also the lives of people affected by the projects they built.
All of these brave programmes fell  afoul of established competitors, and had relatively short lives. However in the ferment of ideas that surrounded  urban developments at that time, some of the ideas of Europeans as to the proper handling of urban land were introduced.  For example, the relatively progressive, although Conservative,  governments of John Robarts and Bill Davis, which ruled Ontario from 1961 to 1985, did buy up large quantities of land with the purpose of making development more coherent. But the experience was that, without any firm foundation in the population for  a greater public involvement, the land was never put to the use that could have transformed the development of our urban centres, and most of it was eventually sold back into private hands.  I remember there was an authenticated story about one leader of the Central Mortgage and Housing Corporation  ---- I think it was Stuart Bates ---- who recommended to Prime Minister Lester Pearson that his government should buy up all the vacant urban land in Ottawa so that they could have the controls needed to build a capital city worthy of the name, but the Prime Minister did not share his enthusiasm, as anyone can see who observes how Ottawa’s impressive Parliamentary precinct has been overwhelmed by the high-rise downtown excrescence that has since been built.
Another issue I took an interest in was the swallowing up of Canada’s best rural land for suburban development. In a country which, although vast, has a very limited amount of useful Class A rural land, this is one of the most egregious examples of governmental neglect.  I remember a Professor Norman Pearson, who was at various times connected to almost every university in Ontario, who made it his specialty to argue for safeguarding the land of the Niagara peninsula which is the biggest area in  Canada capable of growing peaches and other warm-weather fruits.  He was an Englishman who set the mark of his British planning education on this country, but although he marshaled impressive facts about our wanton destruction of this precious piece of land, his warnings went virtually unheeded. I worked on a National Film Board film called Niagara For Sale, in which we recorded various politicians from all levels of government expressing their absolute misunderstanding and indifference to the need.
In general one can say that  Canada’s prevailing attitude towards the use of land has been entirely dominated by the ethos of  urban developers, whose primary interest is in making money. Today the situation in Toronto and Vancouver is verging on the desperate. An acquaintance of mine sold her pretty little house in downtown Toronto for as sum that was $400,000 above her asking price. That was great for her of course but if she wanted to stay in Toronto, all of that money would have been absorbed in buying another property. Instead she moved to Prince Edward county, where she was able to buy a large property on an acre of land for just over the amount in which her previous sale exceeded her asking price.
I myself as few years ago bought a house in Ottawa for $92,000 and sold it as] few years later for something like $268,000, as sum which has turned out to be the only money I have ever saved after a lifetime of work, and on which I am now living my declining years.  That is a crazy illustration of a part of the capitalist ethos that has always been completely out of hand, and seems likely to remain so.