Sunday, August 3, 2014

My Log 434 August 3 2014: Three weighty novels by diverse international authors, each with a global readership

Orhan Pamuk, turkish novelist. The photo is de...
Orhan Pamuk, turkish novelist. The photo is declared copyright-free on Pamuk's official website. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Japanese writer Haruki Murakami
Japanese writer Haruki Murakami (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Cover of "Kafka on the Shore"
Cover of Kafka on the Shore
Cover of "The Museum of Innocence"
Cover of The Museum of Innocence


I have read many novels in the last few months, some of them memorable. The last one I wrote about in this space was The Wind-up Bird Chronicle, by Japanese novelist Haruki Murakami. So today I want to reflect on three more remarkable works, another by Murakami called Kafka On the Shore,  an historical but fictional recreation of the life of Cicero called Imperium, by English writer Robert Harris, and the extraordinary, almost unclassifiable Turkish novel The Museum of Innocence, by Orhan Pamuk.
The meaning of the Japanese and Turkish novels is fairly obscure, but that has not prevented their being translated into 60 languages (selling 11 million copies), in the case of Murakami, 50 languages in the case of Pamuk, while at least one of Harris’s books has been translated into 25 languages.
So there seems little doubt that works that are mysterious and complex as to their meaning are meeting a ready audience around the world.
I will try to elaborate these mysteries without giving too much away of the plots of the books. Kafka on the Shore is about a 15-year-old boy who decides to run away from the home he has shared with his father, a famous sculptor, to go in search of his missing mother and sister.  On leaving home the boy decides to call himself Kafka. After a series of adventures he takes refuge in a  quiet private library in the north of the country, which is presided over by an aloof, beautiful woman, whom he begins to fantasize could be his mother. There is a suggestion that the boy has entered a sort of third dimension of life, because the woman who is the object of his interest is able to appear to him each day as she was when she was 15.
A parallel story, however, also keeps pulsing through the book. That is the story of an old  man called Nakata who, as is established in the first pages, was one of 16 children who during a school expedition undertaken into a forest during the war, were overcome by a mysterious something or other that resulted in them all losing consciousness. All but one of them recovered quickly, and an investigation by the US military was able to come to no conclusion as to what caused the incident. Nakata was the boy who took time to recover, and when he did he was stripped of all memory and most of the human feelings with which we grow into manhood. He finds it difficult to communicate with humans, but has a unique ability to converse with cats. Because of this he is employed by a family of his acquaintance to search for their missing cat.  He is directed on his search by a cat, but this direction has tragic results, and thereafter he is convinced that he can only be saved if he finds what he calls the Entrance Stone.  When he finds it, this stone has he capacity to change its weight, to become immovable at certain times, and easily moved at others: so throughout this strange tale we could be said to be in the realm of magic. This is not something that would normally appeal to me, but the story is written in such a lively manner, the incidents recounted are so interesting, and the characters, though not normal beings, are so fascinating that I had no difficulty in reading to the end of this 600 page book.
As to its meaning, I will have to leave you with what Murakami himself suggests, that there are a number of hidden riddles in the text which it is the challenge fo the reader to solve. Personally I did not spot them. But again, I should emphasize that this writer has a devoted audience of millions of readers all around the world.
I have just finished reading another huge epic, the 530 page novel The Museum of Innocence by Pamuk. I confess this was tougher going, because of its strange structure. It is the chronicle of an obsession, perhaps we could call it a lifelong infatuation held by a 30 year old wealthy Turkish businessman for a 17-year-old, beautiful shopgirl, called Fusun.  He succeeds (without too much trouble) in seducing her and they live 44 days of joyous sex, which ends on the day of his long-planned engagement party to a beautiful and sympathetic fiancee.  His paramour agrees to come to visit him at two pm as usual after the engagement party, but she doesn’t show up plunging him into a life so obsessively dominated by his search for her that, towards the end of the book, one of his friends says he is “not quite right in the head”, a judgment with which I would have to agree.
When the girl does reappear, she is married to a young man whom the hero (if I may use that description) immediately befriends, promising to finance him in making a film in which his wife, Fusun, should be the star.
He dangles his promise before them, and even before he sees that the young husband is not particularly attentive to his wife, he uses the situation to begin showing up at the girl’s home as often as four, sometimes five times a week. She favours him only with the occasional warm glance, but makes it clear she has no interest in resuming their previous relationship. Nevertheless he carries on these visits for eight years, neglecting his business and feeding his obsession to such a degree that he begins to collect everything the girl has touched. For example, he collects 4200 cigarette butts he has snaffled after she has butted them out, he has countless glasses bearing her lipstick, olive pits she has discarded on a side plate, and so on. Over the years he secretly collects every imaginable object, and replaces it with a new one, or a similar one, the next day. These are the objects which, after his paramour’s death, he decides to include in his promised Museum of Innocence.
It is the description of these eight years of his servitude to this young woman that eventually becomes rather wearing at least for this reader. For example, in describing his evenings with the family, he has one chapter of several pages in which every one of 133 sentences begins with the word “sometimes”, the rest of the sentence describing a different action, or inaction.
I suppose what kept one reading this tedious recital is the question as to whether he is ever going to get her into he sack again.  I will not reveal that, but there is an accident, and the final chapters of the book (it has no fewer than 83 chapters) are also rather odd. The protagonist decides to tell the story of his love ife, and chooses the well-known writer Orhan Pamuk to put it into words. Meantime, he embarks, obsessively again, on a world-wide search of small museums (he visited more than 4,000, he said)  which could inspire his decision to actually create a Museum of Innocence, containing the many thousands of artifacts he has collected over the years.
The kicker here is that Pamuk, author of this strange book, has actually created such a museum in Istanbul, which opened in 2012.
I can only pass on the description of the Museum given by the historian Simon Schama who after visiting it, said it would be crazy, “had not Pamuk created in this old house what may be the single most powerfully beautiful, human and affecting work of contemporary art anywhere in the world, at once poetic and darkly comical; tender, and case by case, space by space, aesthetically ravishing.”
 I do have to admit that through this strange method Pamuk in this book manages to provide a deeply authentic-seeming portrait of Istanbul society as it was caught in its traditions between the old Muslim authoritarian world, and its embrace of the values of modernity, such as consumerism, affluence, economic growth, and their accompanying freedom of speech, dignity of the individual and the rights of minorities. As to the first three of these qualities, Pamuk considers Turkey has done relatively well; as to the latter three he is not convinced. Indeed, he himself has had to face a prosecution, which was unsuccessful, that his writings had  undermined the Turkish state.

The third of these excellent novels was possibly the most assured, the most successfully achieved, the most gripping, and probably the most interesting of them all. Robert Harris was an early enthusiast for the leadership of Tony Blair, and he worked in his backrooms alongside his close friend Peter Mandelson. When Mandelson was demoted and denigrated, he decided to stand by him, phoned his friends and acquaintances, and was amazed at how quickly they had all decided to forsake him,  He used his experiences in government to inform the intensely political book he has written about ancient Greece, in which he follows the rise of the notable orator Cicero into the leadership of Rome. The story is told by a slave who became Cicero’s amanuensis (and who invented the first effective shorthand enabling him to take accurate notes of speeches his master made). This book --- written by a natural writer, who had no trouble creating the complex political speeches that are quoted verbatim in its pages ---  came from the pen of a man who had already written best-selling thrillers. His grasp of the politics of ancient Greece is extraordinary, and he managed the whole affair without putting a step wrong.  Once again I found myself marvelling at how the British education system, whatever its failures from a democratic point of view, has been able to turn out such a string of superb novelists, essayists, dramatists, and poets, equal to those produced anywhere in the world. After growing up on a council estate, Harris was educated at Cambridge.

Link of the day: August 3 2014: Jeffrey St. Clair, editor of counterounch.org opens an amusing, ironic window on an aspect of the American dream, by describing how Hillary Clinton, broke, depressed, hardly able to pay her daughter’s school fees as she left the White House, managed in 12 months to put together a nestegg of $35 million. If Hillary could do it, you can do it, surely, even if you are one of those welfare recipients whose grip on life was so diminished by the Clinton cuts to welfare! Read the story, Down and Out with Hillary Clinton, here.

Saturday, August 2, 2014

My Log 433 August 2 2014: Weeks of silence from me, because the events of Gaza have immobilized me while I watch, horrified

"Double Standard" by Carlos Latuff.
"Double Standard" by Carlos Latuff. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
English: A montage of the Gaza War.
English: A montage of the Gaza War. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
English: Dar al-Fadila Association for Orphans...
English: Dar al-Fadila Association for Orphans, consisting of a school, computer center and mosque in Rafah serving 500 children, were destroyed by the Israelis during Israel's assault on Gaza. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
English: An Israeli strike caused a huge explo...
English: An Israeli strike caused a huge explosion in residential area in Gaza. This is during the Israeli assault on Gaza 08-09 Day 17. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Protest against the Israeli attack on the Pale...
Protest against the Israeli attack on the Palestinians of Gaza held at the State Library 4 January 2009 (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Still shot from video footage filmed on the 18...
Still shot from video footage filmed on the 18th day of the War on Gaza showing the destruction sustained from Israeli-Palestinian clash in the area (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
It has been a long time, more than a month, I believe, since I posted anything on this site. During that time I have been reading a number of remarkable novels by writers from various countries (about which, more on a later date); but more recently I have been immobilized by the horrors of the Israeli attack on Gaza.
In recent days I have been following not only the events, but the commentaries on the events, many of which have come to me through the email system, and others have been staged by various TV networks, notably Al Jazeera.
I have been astonished by the claptrap pedalled by the Israeli government spokespersons, who have acted as if the whole problem began with the kidnapping, and later deaths, of three Israeli teenagers. They never mention that the Israelis killed two Palestinian teenagers a month before; or that, in their frantic search for the missing Israeli teenagers (a phony event, as it happens, because it has been revealed that they knew from the start the fate of these boys) the Israelis killed at least 14 people. Or that killings of Palestinians by Israelis have been continuing year by year.
The fact, established by various people with historical knowledge of the Israel-Palestinians imbroglio, is that the continuing occupation of the West Bank by Israel is what lies at the core of this dispute. The fact is, Israel has blocked every effort to create a peace that would be lasting, preferring, instead, to illegally occupy these lands by building settlements which have so changed the situation on the ground that Israel now seems to be in an unassailable position, so long as it can keep intact its military might, for which it seems to depend entirely on he United States.
A commentary by a Beirut academic named Rami Khouri, whose name is familiar from his having contributed over the years to The Ottawa Citizen, really summarized the facts of what has been happening on the ground. He spoke the day at the ceasefire arranged by Obama and Ban Ke Moon broke down. He pointed to the fact that the agreement for a ceasefire did not mention what John Kerry mentioned later in a press conference, that Israel would be free to pursue its project to destroy tunnels that lay behind the area they had occupied .  That is not a ceasefire, when one side is given the right to continue its operations, he said. And it illustrated the basic problem with the role of the United States as intermediary.
Traditionally, over the many years of this conflict, he said, the United States has treated the demands and wishes of Israel as the bottom line that must first be satisfied, and once that is done the Palestinians are left to pick up the crumbs of whatever is left over. Evidently, this so-called ceasefire which gave the Israelis authority to continue with their work was the best deal Kerry could get out of Netanyahu.  This of course can have come as no surprise to those who were paying attention, for in talking about the coming ceasefire I heard Netanyahu say, straight out, that ceasefire or no ceasefire, Israel would not be deterred from its mission to destroy all the tunnels.
Khouri called this incompetent diplomacy by the United States. And in looking forward to measures that might be taken to bring further peace--- first, a ceasefire, then a step towards a permanent solution --- he hoped that Egypt would step in and work from a neutral position --- something that can no longer be guaranteed --- and that other powers, more friendly to Hamas than those under the control of the United States (among whom he seemed to include all Western powers like those in Europe, Canada and so on), powers like Turkey, Qatar, and some others might step into a more prominent role of mediation.  Only thus, said Khouri, would it be possible to look forward to serious efforts of diplomacy, to replace the amateurish diplomacy practised by the Americans.  The Americans, though they have lost their right to mediate because of their total support for everything Israeli, would have to be involved in such negotiations because they are the only power trusted by Israel, he said.
When an interviewer directed his attention  to the criticism expressed by Obama of the shelling of a UN shelter for 3500 people, resulting in the killing of 19 people and wounding of countless others, Khouri said, “We cannot any longer take  notice of what the Americans say, what they do is what counts. And they have, at the same time, renewed their support of Israel by sending them more of the arms and ammunition they are using to devastate the  refugee camps of Gaza.”
Following that pertinent interview, Al Jazeera yesterday screened a revealing episode of their daily programme Inside Story, with, as guests, Daniel Levy, a former adviser to an Israeli Prime Minister who is now director of  a Middle East and African programme for the European Council of Foreign Relations, Mustafa Barghouti, secretary-general of  the Palestine National Initiative, and Shashank Joshi, a research fellow of the Royal United Services Institute, of London. They were agreed with Rami Khouri’s point that the so-called ceasefire was not in fact a real ceasefire, since Israel was given authority to continue with its destructive activities: in other words, the Americans, as usual, had agreed to the demands of Israel, without which there would have been no ceasefire.  Levy said Israel had become accustomed to acting with impunity in relation to the Palestinians, and this was beginning to be something that was working against their best interests. Bargouti rejected the idea, pedalled by the Western media, that the Palestinians were not united: he said they were, in fact, united, and had been planning to send a delegation to Cairo for more serious talks about the future that would have included all Palestinian factions. He compared this situation to one a few years earlier when Israel told Abbas, the Palestinian leader, that they were ready to talk about a Palestinian state, but he had to know that such a state would have an Israeli military presence, the Israelis would not withdraw from their present occupation status, they would not agree  that Jerusalem should be capital of such a state, so with that information, they should go ahead and negotiate.  Of course, said Levy, that was not a serious negotiation. He said that in the current situation the US would have to decide whether it was a mediator or a party to the struggle: in the latter case, it could no longer be a mediator. He added that the best route for the Palestinians would be to eschew the firing of rockets, but concentrate on opposing the occupation by civil disobedient, non-violent methods within the ambit of international law.
Bargouti said in the current situation Israel and the United States were insisting that Palestinians did not have equal rights to be considered normal human beings as the Israelis. They were, he said, not entitled to defend themselves when attacked (according to this American/Israeli position), they were not entitled to resist occupation, and they were not entitled to live ordinary life with the amenities necessary to carry on their daily activities. Meanwhile Israel conducts one massacre after another on them.
One striking thing is that the leaders of the western world automatically assume that in case of breakdown, the fault lies entirely with the Palestinians. Yet the facts on the ground, the thousands of people killed and wounded on one side compared with the few on the other, the insensate destruction of houses, the bombing of schools, hospitals, water and power plants, what seems like the determination to destroy the life of Gaza  once and for all, leave no doubt as to which is the injured party here.
I have been reading a lot of things bearing on this issue recently, much of it extremely illuminating. Especially interesting is the growing body of work by disillusioned Zionists of one kind or another--- soldiers who finally could no longer stomach their oppressive role in keeping the Palestinians under control, academics who could no longer swallow the myths of the creation of Israel by the Zionists, and so on.
All of these make it plain that  Israel has occupied Palestine using the very methods of terrorism, brutal occupation, and ethnic cleansing, as it is now called, that they now self-righteously say make their current opponents beyond the pale: they won’t even talk to people who are doing what their own leaders (men who later became Prime Ministers of Israel) did many years ago.
An interesting article in this week’s Guardian Weekly quotes an Israeli peace activist as saying that as a people who were traumatised over centuries by their experiences in Europe, the Israelis now have a sense that people owe them, a sense that allows them to ask “who are you to tell us what to do?”
The author quotes  another Israel peace activist as saying that when Palestinians die, “Israelis don’t deny they have died, but they’ve simply done a mental process that blames the Palestinian deaths on Palestinians themselves.”

Most of the commentators who have impressed me have pointed to world opinion as the only factor which could rescue the situation from its current stalemate. And the fact seems to be that opinion has recently been changing towards more sympathy for the Palestinians, as evidenced by the demonstrations in their favour recently throughout the world. Unfortunately, so far this has had almost no effect on politics. But as the people of the world mobilize to try to bring the Palestinian suffering to an end, it seems obvious Israel will eventually be forced to negotiate seriously with the people whose lands, homes, businesses and culture they have occupied and/or destroyed.

Monday, June 30, 2014

My Log 432 June 30 2014: Two amazing works by Japanese novelist Haruki Murakami, difficult to describe, hard to catch their real meaning, but nevertheless a great read

English: Haruki_Murakami_at_the_Jerusalem_Prize
English: Haruki_Murakami_at_the_Jerusalem_Prize (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Japanese writer Haruki Murakami
Japanese writer Haruki Murakami (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
English: The signature of Haruki Murakami
English: The signature of Haruki Murakami (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Cover of "Kafka on the Shore"
Cover of Kafka on the Shore
Cover of "The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle: A N...
Cover of The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle: A Novel
I have spent a lot of time recently reading two 600-page novels by a Japanese writer I had never before read, Haruki Murakami, who is apparently ranked right up there with such novelists as Yukio Mishima (remembered as a rightwing fanatic who took his own life by the ritual form called seppuku), Kobo Abe (author of the unforgettable Woman of the Dunes, which was also made into a marvellous film),  and Kenzeburo Oe (winner of the Nobel Prize for Literature).
I am not well versed in Japanese literature, but have read enough to know that one cannot expect anything ordinary from their novelists of quality and certainly these two works by  Murakami fulfil that expectation.  Murakami has written 13 novels, of which The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle published in 1997 is the eighth, and  Kafka On the Shore, the second of the two I have read, was published in 2002.
It is hard to say which strikes the foreign reader as the stranger of the two, although the strangeness of his subjects and his approach to them does not seem to have put off foreign readers, because he is said to have been translated into fifty languages, has sold millions of copies world-wide, and has won innumerable prizes and accolades abroad.
The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle  tells the story of a man who has recently quit his job and is living contentedly at home looking after the household while his wife earns their daily bread. One important thing he has to do as the book opens is to find their cat, that has run away, and without which the wife says she would find it difficult to live. So, he goes along the road they live on into an alley where there is an empty, abandoned house that can  be reached only by climbing over a fence. He thought the cat might have taken refuge there, but when he finds himself in the yard of this house he encounters a 16-year-old girl with whom he enters into an elaborate conversation. There is also some sort of statue of a bird, which our protagonist, Mr Okado identifies with the song of real birds that he has heard singing while in the yard, singing a strange, wind-up kind of song, and when he explains this to the young girl she takes to calling him Mr. Wind-Up-Bird. Also in the yard the young girl points out a disused well, and Mr. Okada throws a stone into it and hears a thud as it falls, so that he knows the well is empty of water.
Though he finds these things --- all of which as the story develops begin to play an important role in the narrative --- he does not find the runaway cat. And meantime he has received a strange phone call from an unknown female voice which nevertheless says it knows him intimately, but ho says that ten minutes of his time should be enough for her purposes.
Meantime, his wife who has often worked late, does not come home after leaving for work one day, and it is her brother, a man very successful in Japanese public life who Mr Okada hates and his wife seldom speaks to, who arrives to tell him his wife has left him for a man who has been her lover for some months. He is reluctant to believe him, and astonished that she should have depended on her brother to bring him the news. Such is his disorientation that Mr. Okada continues to climb the fence into the yard, which is watched almost every hour of every day by the 16-year-old girl, with whom he continues to have interesting conversations.
Eventually, Mr, Okada takes to going to sit before the city’s railway station in the hope that he might spot his wife. But there he is approached by a powerful woman who asks him to follow her, and thus begins a different part of the story. Mr Okada is seduced by three women, or it may be even more, I lost count, including a pair of sisters called Malta and Crete, because they had once lived in Malta and Crete. An old man of his acquaintance before dying tells him a horrendous story about atrocities he had committed and seen committed while a member of the Japanese invasion force in China before the Second World War, which ended in his being thrown for dead down a well.
These characters all play into Mr. Okada’s odyssey as he tries his best to get his wife back.  His relationships with the women cannot be described as salutary, except with the young schoolgirl with whom he continues to have long-distance communication, the impression being given that she has fallen for him. 
The events in this novel are extraordinary, seem somehow to be sort of peripheral to the characters involved in them, and it all works through to a conclusion that is unlike any real conclusion.  It is a very strange mixture, this story, but told with such immense narrative drive that I could not put it down, while wondering why else I would be reading it.
Kafka On the Shore, the second novel I read, is even stranger. It has two main protagonists: one, a 15-year-old boy who decides to run away from home, a home that had been abandoned many years before by his mother, of whom he retains only vague memories, and from whom, somehow his sister and brother had disappeared also.  His father had cursed him, he believed, saying that, like Odysseus, he would murder his father, sleep with his mother and betray his sister. He ends up in a private library presided over by a remarkably beautiful 50-year-old woman whom he immediately begins to fantasize is his lost mother.  His father,  a famous sculptor, has meantime been murdered, and the police are searching for his missing son.
The second protagonist is a shell of a person which is all that remains of a child who suffered a terrible humiliation during a mysterious incident in which schoolchildren were all struck unconscious by something that was never identified, in spite of a massive, secret investigation by the U.S. Army. All the affected children recovered after a few hours, except for this one boy Nakata, who was sent to a hospital, and who, when he did emerge from his coma, was a personality who had been emptied of memory, who never learned to read or write, and whose premier talent was the ability to talk to cats.
As in the previous book there is one really horrifying incident described that vitally affects the narrative, and it is this that leads to the murder of the sculptor, a man who has been in the habit of collecting cats and beheading them so that their souls could be made into a wondrous flute.
This strange person takes over the second part of the novel in which the author deliberately identifies a sort of third dimension to life in which people can appear as  their 15-year-old selves 35 years after the event, and in which strange intuitions are needed that belong to a world that I personally have always thought of as rubbish. I kept asking myself why I was reading this, given my attitude towards such things, and again the answer lay in the amazing strength with which the tale was told and the incredible story-telling skills exhibited in its telling.
These are two of the hardest books that I have ever tried to describe in writing, and I am only too conscious of the inadequacy of what appears above. All I can add is that anyone who finds that my descriptions whet their curiosity at all should try to read these books, which I personally have found among the most rewarding of novels I have ever read.