Monday, June 9, 2014

My Log 428 June 9 2014: Inconvenient indeed, those Indians! Thomas King’s remarkable book provides an unanswerable case against colonialism

Karl Bodmer: Indians hunting the bison. Tablea...
Karl Bodmer: Indians hunting the bison. Maximilian Prince of Wied's Travels in the Interior of North America, during the years 1832–1834; published London 1843–1844. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Sitting Bull and Buffalo Bill, 1885
Sitting Bull and Buffalo Bill, 1885 (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Novelist Thomas King’s remarkable book about his people, the indigenous of North America, was published two years ago, but somehow or other I never picked up on it until this last week, when, on vacation in Europe, I finally found time to read it. It is called The Inconvenient Indian, a slightly throw-away title that gives a clue to the humorous, ironical tone in which the book is written.
King has sub-titled his book A Curious Account of Native people in North America and again here the use of the word “curious” is rather ambiguous. Curious, in what way?
His early chapters --- curiously enough, as I thought while reading them --- contained long lists of Indians who had been actors in Hollywood movies, of non-Indians who had portrayed Indians in Hollywood movies, and various other things like that which to a serious-minded student of the history of these people all seemed slightly facetious.
Maybe it was King’s way of suggesting that  one shouldn’t be too solemn about these things, but the serious purpose appeared to be the emphasize that non-Indian people throughout North America had been schooled to see Indians as stereotypes, not as real, live people, but as constructs of someone’s entertainment sources (for example.)  This point was more than adequately made when he revealed that by 1883, when Buffalo Bill Cody started his famous Wild West show, the self-perception of North American indigenous people was already so degenerated, even among those who had led the resistance,  that many of the latter-day “Indian” heroes were lining up to join Cody’s show.  Before the 1880s were out, such leaders as Red Cloud had joined the circus, followed in 1885 by Sitting Bull, later the Metis leader Gabriel Dumont (1886), while heroes such as Chief Joseph and Geronimo had joined Col Frederick T. Cummins’s Life on the Plains exposition when it opened in New York in 1903.
“Whatever else these shows were,” comments King, “they were an intriguing alternative to being locked down on a reservation or sitting alone in a prison cell. Keep in mind, many of these individuals were considered dangerous by North America. After all the Battle of the Little Bighorn and Wounded Knee were still in the rear-view mirror, and at the turn of the century, no one was quite sure what might appear up ahead through the windshield.”
Allow me to draw attention to King’s  use of yet another ambiguous adjective:”intriguing.”   Like “inconvenient” and “curious” in his book’s title, these three words are used in an ambiguous sense, and since King is an expert novelist, we can assume his use of them in this way was deliberate.
Now any reasonably objective person who has examined the historical record of European colonialism, wherever it manifested itself, would surely have to agree with the following proposition:   wherever the colonialists landed, they wanted the land, and everywhere they took it.  That is what happened in Africa, Australia, New Zealand and throughout North and South America. And the differences between these places were merely ones of degree, all within the ambiance of their wanting and taking the land, and to hell with the consequences. Finding the lands in these places populated by peoples whom they considered inferior, they used every stratagem at their disposal, including the mind-blowing assumption that these lands were unoccupied, to justify what was, in effect, their theft of someone else’s property. It was fortunate for the colonialists that the indigenous people whom they found already in occupation did not think of the land and their ownership of it in the same, grasping, greedy way as did their invaders. In the words of a Cree hunter whom I interviewed in the 1970s, their concept of “ownership” was entirely different, all wrapped up with their subsistence on the land, along with that of the animals on whom they depended for their food. “Do you own the land?” I asked him, a question that was asked in the middle of a hurricane-like assault on his land by  invading Euro-Canadians.  “Well,” said Sam Blacksmith, who had lived his entire life in the northern Quebec bush as a hunter and trapper, “people tell us we own it. But in the end everybody dies, so nothing can be predicted.” Talk about ambiguity: one understands where Thomas King gets it from!
Around the 100-page mark, King gets serious, and I noted these two vigorous paragraphs:
“…for the (English) or (French)…. Indians were simply humans at an early point in the evolution of the species. They were savages with no understanding of orthodox theology, devoid of complex language, and lacking civilized manners. Barbarians, certainly, and quite possibly minions of the devil. But human beings, none the less. And as such, many colonists believed that Native people could be civilized and educated, believed that there was, within the Indians, the possibility for enlightenment.
“Extermination dominated the early contact period, assimilation the latter, until finally, in the nineteenth century, they came together in an amalgam of militarism and social theory that allowed North America to mount a series of benevolent assaults on Native people. Assaults facilitated by force of arms, deception and coercion, assaults that sought to dismantle Native culture with missionary zeal and humanitarian paternalism, and to replace it with something that Whites could recognize.”
The rest of Thomas King’s book is an eloquent filling-in of the details of these various assaults. In the following paragraphs he gives primacy to the warrior work of the Christians --- Jesuit, Anglican, Methodist, Presbyterian, Puritan, Baptist, Quakers, Franciscan and even Russian Orthodox --- all of them played their part in the conquest of North America. Bruce Trigger’s monumental historical masterpiece The Children of Aataentsic (1975), establishes beyond a doubt the efficacy with which these Christian groups --- in his case he was dealing with the Jesuits, and their impact on the Hurons --- as soon as they came in contact with indigenous Americans, completely undermined their belief systems, weakening them to such an extent within 20 years that, attacked by the Iroquois, they collapsed like a pack of cards, all their certainties about their lives having been demolished.
I have read a lot of the written record and I cannot say I found a single fact or opinion in King’s book with which I do not agree. In some places he seems to have been too soft in his denunciations. For example, at one point unless my memory betrays me, he says various efforts were made to turn Indians into farmers, and here I thought he could have been even tougher, more condemnatory than he was, because of the the historical record (read Sarah Carter’s studies of  Western Canadian history, particularly Lost Harvests  written in 1993.)  In that carefully researched book she shows that, having responded to the call to them to become farmers, indigenous people were then deliberately deprived of markets for their produce. In other words, the colonizers were determined that the indigenous people could never win, no matter what they did.
In this infamous tale King gives equal billing to the United States and Canada, the major difference being that in the United States military means were the major weapon of assault, in  Canada it was all done rather by legislation,  generation after generation  of legislation designed to deprive indigenous people of everything that meant anything to them --- rituals, beliefs, languages, and above all, their economies, especially those like that of the Ojibway of the Lake of the Woods area which were diversified and soundly based.  King’s indictment is severe, but it could have been even more severe, if proving the infamy of the attackers had been his primary object.
These are not serious criticisms of King’s book, which is beautifully written, entirely convincing, and a major weapon for public education on a subject that, somehow or other --- we cannot suppose this was accidental --- has somehow fallen between the cracks of our educational system.



Enhanced by Zemanta

Sunday, June 1, 2014

My Log 427 June 1 2014: Matthiessen book The Tree Where Man Was Born, written half a century ago, is a wonderful wistful plea for a better world

tsetse fly which transmits sleeping sickness
tsetse fly which transmits sleeping sickness (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
English: Peter Matthiessen in the WNYC studios...
Peter Matthiessen (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Julius Nyerere as leader of the Legislative Co...
Julius Nyerere (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Cover of "Tree Where Man Was Born"
Cover of Tree Where Man Was Born
It is a sign of the power of the late Peter Matthiessen’s books, and of his stature as a writer, that on his death, my second-hand bookshop in Montreal, The Word, one of the best I have encountered anywhere, could find only one of his books in their huge collection of the finest literature.
When I drew his death to their attention they put his book on his travels to the Antarctic in their window, and, having never read that one, I snapped it up.  A couple of days later the owner Adrian came at me on the street waving a large book by Matthiessen called The Tree Where Man Was Born, a beautiful book printed in 1972 by Dutton of New York, in which the writer recorded several trips he had made to the African continent, where he observed the wildlife and the human inhabitants with the same practised anthropological eye.
Along with the 100,000 words of Matthiessen’s text the book contains magnificent photos taken by Eliot Porter, who is given equal billing on the book’s title page.
I snapped up this book as well, and am just finished reading it. As usual Matthiessen’s prose is of such quality that one is constantly tempted to reproduce great quantities of it. But what amazed me more in this book is the depth of his knowledge of the wildlife of the relatively small area of Africa in which he travelled, and his profound knowledge of the history of each of the small groups of people --- often displaced people from some other area of the continent --- whom he encountered.
His journeyings took him down Kenya into the northern reaches of Tanzania, or Tanganyika, as it was known when he first visited it.  I remember clearly as a correspondent in London, being told by the Colonial secretary of the time that this large country was given its independence, Iain Macleod, that the decision was made “entirely because of Julius Nyerere.” It is true Nyerere was a sterling fellow, educated at Edinburgh university, but he was almost the only university graduate in the whole country, and I seem to remember that at the time of the handing over, the annual budget of Tanganyika was something  around 20 million pounds. Not much wonder that a few years later I was told by an amiable Canadian diplomat who had been our high commissioner there for some years, that “I am in favour of Julius Nyerere….of course nothing works in his country….but he deserves our support.”
Of course, Matthiessen was neither seeking, nor offering,  political insight, but was keen to investigate the actual conditions of the African tribesmen, their relations with their animals and land, and the extent to which the imposed ideas of Western-educated people were making life for them more or less impossible.
“In Tanzania,” he writes (remember, this book was published 52 years ago!), “ intensive agriculture is seen as the solution to malnutrition and unemployment, and a population increase is encouraged.But except in the highlands the red earths of East Africa are too poor to support permanent agriculture, and where they are fertile, the soils are soon impoverished by the plow, which lays them bare to cycles of fierce sun and leeching rain. In the wet season the ground is muck, and in the dry a hard-caked dusty stone. Wind and rain erode a soil that may have taken centuries to form, and there is desert. In Ethiopia, Madagascar and throughout East Africa one sees this fatal erosion of thin fragile lateritic soils; the rust red of the laterite comes to the surface of the African landscape like blood welling in scraped skin.”
This is so beautifully described one almost feels there is nothing more to be said.
But elsewhere in the book Matthiessen devotes a lot of time to observing elephants:
“I can watch elephants for hours at a time, for sooner or later the elephant will do something very strange such as mow grass with its toenails or draw the tusks from the rotted carcass of another elephant and and carry them off into the bush There is mystery behind that masked gray visage, an ancient life force, delicate and mighty, awesome and enchanted, commanding the silence ordinarily reserved for mountain peaks, great fires, and the sea.”
Still Matthiessen appears to have almost given up hope that the elephant will survive:
“…even very honest governments may not be able to withstand political pressure to provide meat for the people….park revenues from meat and hides and tusks could be considerable, and this temptation may prove impossible to resist for the new governments….A stubborn fight for animal preservation in disregard of people and their famine-haunted future would only be the culminating failure of the western civilization that through its blind administration of vaccines and quinine has upset the ecologies of a whole continent… Thus wildlife must be treated in terms of resource management in this new Africa which includes, besides gazelles, a growing horde of tattered humans who squat for days and weeks and months and years on end, in a seeming trance, awaiting hope.”
The elephant problem is the reverse side of the problem of livestock. Matthiessen observes that in small numbers cattle were no threat to the African landscape, but with the coming of the white man, a conflict has emerged. “The Europeans saw livestock as a sign of promise in the heathen: what was good for the white in Europe was good for the black in Africa, and that was that.” Thus was undertaken a vast campaign of wholesale slaughter of wild game, in the hope of ridding the country of the fatal tsetse flies, a useless slaughter as it turns out because it has become known that the tsetse prefers warthog, giraffes and buffaloes, so that “the vast majority of victims died in vain.”
And then this passage: “Game control, tsetse control, fenced water points, poaching --- everywhere wild animals made way for creatures which even from the point of view of economics seem very much less efficient than themselves. The ancestors of the wild animals have been evolving for 70 million years; the modern species, three quarters of a million years old, form the last great population of wild animals left on earth. Over their long evolutionary course, they have adapted to the heat and rain, to poor soils and coarse vegetation, and because they had time to specialize, a dozen species can feed in the same area without competing; rhino, giraffe and gerenik are browsers of leaves and shrubs, while zebra, topi and wildebeest are grazers; buffalo, elephant, eland, impala, and most other antelope do both. Zebras eat standing hay, and wildebeest and kongonis half-grown grass, leaving the newest growth to the gazelles; the topi has a taste for the rank meadow grass that most other antelopes avoid…..all have water-conserving mechanisms that permit them to go without water for days at a time….Cattle by comparison must be brought to water every day or two, and waste coarse grasses used by the wild animals.” It struck me during the many years that, as a journalist, I spent fiddling around environmental issues, how little we know of how Nature works. And this book is evidence for that belief. 
In one passage he gives a catalogue of the equipment needed before anyone ventures out into the African bush in a motor vehicle. Surrounded by wild animals, many of which can be extremely dangerous, fear of breakdown is real: and it reminded me of a trip I took once between Hay River and Fort Smith, in the Northwest Territories, to deliver a small weekly newspaper published in the first of these two small towns. The owner of the truck (and publisher of the newspaper) we were travelling in across the empty 180 mile distance, needed a panoply of extra materials in case of breakdown. In the event, his tail pipe dropped off in the middle of the night, and in below minus 30 degree weather he had to get down with his supplies of mending wire, to fix the problem. In Africa, it was the dry, dusty land and the wildlife that demanded immense caution; in Canada, it was the cold we had to confront.
There is so much meat in this book, informationally speaking, that I feel I  am incapable of making a more measured judgment of it, informed as it is by the author’s profound knowledge, allied to his unique capacity to describe what he was observing. It is interesting that for all his respect for these pre-industrial people of Africa, Matthiessen also describes a profound admiration for the strange assortment of white adventurers, ecologists, wildlife enthusiasts, who were among the first to bring the outside world detailed descriptions of the needs and the joys of this unique continent. Matthiessen himself benefitted immensely from the help of many of these pioneering people and is unstinted in his praise of them, while not neglecting to point out the sometimes wild aspects of their view of their roles.
His last chapter is  wonderful, an account of travelling among two groups of almost extinct people, small people, who appear to have intermarried along the way with people coming into their district, but who, when Matthiessen encountered them, were living so fundamental a life that they did not even have real houses, but merely sheltered in times of rain under makeshift shelters that they erected. One of these peoples, called the Hadza, would appear to require, if they are to have a future, game-cropping arrangements of some kind. They were encouraged in this by a Swedish man living among them, Peter Enderlein, who would like to try game-ranching to support them. “But he has received little support for this scheme, or any other and for the moment must content himself with shooting the animals instead.” Meantime he spends most of his time supplying food for the impounded Hadza, who are not supposed to leave their settlement, much less revert to their old lives in the bush. Matthiessen got the impression the man was almost at the end of his tether, and was hardly surprised when, some months later he received a note from him saying: “It seems my time in Hadza Land has come to an end. I was recently called to a meeting in Mbulu to discuss my project but I found myself the witch in a medieval  witchhunt where the bonfire was built and the match already lighted.” He was accused of wanting to keep the Africans primitive and naked and turn them back to the bush, and various other accusations of an unsavoury kind, none of which was remotely true. Such people as he was trying to defend do not find favour with modern governments, either in Africa or elsewhere.
In the last two paragraphs Matthiessen records that the Hadza women were out gathering roots and tubers, and also the nut of the baobab tree which, “pounded on a stone and cooked a little, provides food for five months of the year. The still air of the hillside quakes with the pound of rock on rock, and in this place so distant from the world, the steady sound is an echo of the Stone Age.” Traditionally the baobab provided shelter, fibre thread,  honey and water, as well as material for baby rattles and drinking cups. But today young baobab are killed by fires, set by the strangers who clear the country for their herds and gardens “and the tree where man was born is dying out in Hadza Land.”
“Soon the young hunters, returning homeward, come in single file between the trees, skins black against black silhouetted thorn. One has an imbra (a marimba) and in wistful monotony, in hesitation step, the naked forms with their small bows pass one by one in a slow dance of childhood. The figures wind in and out among black thorn and tawny twilight grass and vanish. Once more as in a dream, like a band of the Old People, the small Gumba, who long ago went into hiding in the earth.”
Such is the writing of one of our great masters.

This is a book to be cherished by anyone.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Wednesday, May 21, 2014

My Log 426 May 21 2014: Superb biography of Ryszard Kapuscinski, the Polish Communist widely regarded as the greatest reporter of modern times

Ryszard Kapuściński (1932-2007), Polish writer...
Ryszard Kapuściński (1932-2007), Polish writer and journalist (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Ryszard Kapuscinski
Ryszard Kapuscinski (Photo credit: teachandlearn)
I have just read a fascinating biography of the remarkable Polish journalist Ryszard Kapuscinski, a book first published in Polish in 2010, three years after the journalist’s death, and in English last year. The book by Artur Domoslawski, received rapturous reviews in English, but was the subject of a law suit issued by Kapuscinski’s widow, who claimed it defamed the writer and invaded his privacy, and as a result of which the book was withdrawn from circulation by its publisher  Verso, a left-wing publisher of New York and London.
This is a shame because although the book does investigate, among other aspects of the journalist’s character, certain aspects of his attitude to precise truth, it is written in such a sympathetic way as to leave no doubt that the author Domoslawski was an admirer --- one might say, a fervid admirer, like so many others who knew him --- of the journalist and his works.
An especially fascinating aspect of the book is the detailed description of the relationship between the free-wheeling foreign reporter exercising his genius on the problems of modern Africa, Asia and Latin America --- to the eventual admiration of the entire world --- and the Communist party functionaries to whom every word he wrote had to be acceptable..
Kapuscinski was born in 1932 in a small town that is now part of Belarus, the son of primary school teachers who, during the war, moved from place to place to avoid the possibility that they might be deported to the East. The child had a standard education, showed some talent at writing poetry at an early age, and at the age of 16, before he had graduated from high school, joined the recently-founded official Communist youth organization, the ZMP. Two years later he began working for a Youth newspaper, a job he suspended for five years while he studied at university. When he was 20 he married a girl who later became a doctor and was his wife for the rest of his life, and who had to live through his long absences from home as he toured the world.  
He became a member of the Polish United Workers’ Party, the governing Communist party, and by this time was a firm believer in Communism as the hope for a better, more equal Poland.
He was only 24 when he was sent on the first of many foreign assignments. At first he worked for a succession of journals, or newspapers, and later for the Polish News Agency. All of these fell under the control of the Central Committee (of the Party) press office, whose official line fairly rigorously followed the official line set in Moscow. Therefore every variation from the official line had to be debated by the apparatchiks of head office, and from the first Kapuscinski’s writings raised  severe questions for  these bureaucrats.
From the first, equally, he had been careful to make friendly contacts with well-placed people in the party regime, and equally from the first he supplemented his emotionally accurate reportage with bulletins intended not for publication but for the eyes only of  people who needed to know what was going on in the area he was covering. In one of his earliest years, he wrote 15 of these bulletins, which were apparently well received, and fended off the very lively possibility that his brilliant reportage might have opened him to accusations of disloyalty to the ideals of Communism.
He never had an easy time of it as a foreign correspondent, because two or three publications for which he wrote and the news agency were always short of money, and in any case paid extremely low wages. He was paid $300 a month, which was, as the author says, “peanuts” for a roving reporter expected to cover the whole continent. This was so more particularly because from the first Kapuscinski was fascinated by the unique qualities of African life, appalled by the colonial history Africans had had to suffer over many decades, and temperamentally sided always with the underdog. So he fell in love, as the author describes it, with the idea of revolution, and wrote in support even of revolutions --- Che Guevara’s efforts in Bolivia were a prime example --- that were regarded as almost anti-party foolishness by the big shots in Moscow, and even by his immediate bosses in Warsaw.
He soon became renowned in Poland for his unusual detailed reporting, which concentrated on the people at the grassroots level of anything he was describing, but his world fame did not come until his remarkable book on Haile Selassie was published in an edition of 5000 copies in New York. It was received with unanimous acclaim by critics, but even that on such a remote subject of little intrinsic interest to Americans did not guarantee sales of more than a few thousand of the second printing. Nevertheless, this was the beginning of Kapuscinski’s global fame, which escalated with the publication of each of his books. His basic subject was the ending of colonialism in Africa Latin America, Central America, right up to the collapse of the Soviet Union.
Domoslawski goes into some detail about what critics have felt was Kapuscinski’s free and easy way with basic facts. He argues, first, that he created himself as a principle character, inventing a busy military career for his father for instance, and later carefully creating an image of himself as a correspondent who was present at some revolutions that he actually wrote about only after the event. And also, he says, the journalist, an imaginative fellow, invented some of the details that he reported; for example, he reported that a small dog owned by the Ethiopian emperor was allowed to piss on people’s shoes, for which a special courtier was retained to follow the great man everywhere and wipe clean the misdemenors of this dog. That courtier apparently never existed.
This is why Kapuscinski called his style of reporting “creative reportage”, a method of recording what was happening before his eyes that placed him in a category something like that of Hunter S. Thompson, who had a tendency to invent false information about politicians he disapproved of.
I don’t think Kapuscinsi did that quite so blatantly, but he was regarded as something of a fantasist, and regarded people like Gabriel Garcia Marquez, inventor of “magic realism” who became one of his most fervent admirers, as an important influence.
After his death, some diligent researchers in the period known as “lustration” --- that is, revealing from the archives the crimes committed by prominent people  during the years of authoritarian governments --- accused Kapuscinski of having worked for the intelligence services. Domoslawski deals with this accusation in detail: his examination of the archives shows that, indeed, Kapuscinski was recorded as a willing informant for the security services, but in fact he never reported anything to them that was not already easily available to everybody. His position in this regard was equivalent, as the author points out, to some 400 American reporters and their governing agencies, who are known to have collaborated with the CIA. So, it is safe to say that all efforts to besmirch the name of this exceptional reporter and literary artist have failed miserably, and he continues to be viewed with something approaching adoration around the world. In his lifetime --- he died in 2007, at the age of 74 --- his books were published in the languages of countless countries,  he was an invited lecturer in at least 13 universities and received countless awards and was spoken of as a likely future recipient of the Nobel Prize for literature, something he never lived to see.
Another interesting section of this biography is where the author attempts to isolate from Kapuscnski’s voluminous writings exactly what were his attitudes towards the modern world.  This shows that his basic approach was that 20 per cent of the world’s population are privileged, and 80 per cent are not. Therefore it is evident that in the future these 80 per cent will be demanding their share of the fruits of the earth. He was proud of having given to these 80 per cent a voice that previously --- and indeed, in most places, until this moment --- they have not had.
I want to add a personal note to this. Without wanting to make any comparison between my own lifetime in the media of the Western world and the dazzling career of this great reporter, I was interested because I could identify with much that he went through.  I appreciated how he managed to find a method of describing reality that would not offend his bureaucratic bosses. That was a much tougher situation than anything I had to confront during my own career: but the fact is, for anyone like me who did not agree with the politics of the newspapers and agencies for which I worked, many stratagems similar to those used by Kapuscinski were necessary. As I have written elsewhere, I had to become skilful in suggesting things that I did not have the freedom to write directly. My attitude to my colleagues and their belief that they were exercising freedom of expression is that I felt they were self-deluded. The most abject followers of the capitalist programme of their newspapers or agencies would have been amazed if they had at any moment tried to write something in favor of, for example, socialism, or the trade union movement, as distinct from the party-line capitalism, whose parameters they knew and observed meticulously.
I identified with Kapuscinski’s attitudes when he arrived among the people of the colonial regimes in Africa. At around the same time as he was discovering them, so was I on various trips I made. And the description given  of one of his friends arriving among the the white populations of Africa closely agree with my own observations:

….the whites they meet in Tanganyika are “ghastly, even in terms of facial appearance,” whatever the nationality: Germans, Britons, Belgians, Poles…. Abominable types, losers who flocked to Africa because things hadn’t worked out for them anywhere else, upstarts, exploiters of the local population, and, without exception, racists. They run bars and hotels --- they are ‘petty businessmen’. One of the people they encounter goes about with a monkey, because ‘he’d rather drink with a chimp than a black.’  These are the typical remnants of the colonial class whom Kapuscinski encountered in Africa: the face of Europe, which came to Africa to ‘spread civilization among the savages.’

I had much the same feeling when I visited Southern Rhodesia in the 1960s. And in a later book Kapuscinski writes:
The philosophy that inspired the construction of Kolyma and Auschwitz, one of obsessive contempt and hatred, vileness and brutality, was formulated and set down centuries earlier by the captains of the Martha and the Progresso, and the Mary Ann and the Rainbow, as they sat in their cabins glaring out the portholes at groves of palm trees and sun-warmed beaches, waiting aboard their ships anchored off the island of Zanzibar, for the next batch of black slaves to be loaded.

Overall, Domoslawski gives full recognition to Kapuscinski’s charm, his gentle manners, the fact that he was a magnet for tens of thousands of eager young people anxious to learn more about the world, people not afraid to confront “the other” ---one of Kapuscinski’s  favorite subjects, learning to get along with everybody, which, he said, lies at the basis of any possibility for a successful future.







Enhanced by Zemanta

Monday, May 19, 2014

My Log 425 May 19 2014: A brilliant, moving TV investigation of the Israel/Palestinian issue by a young American Jew

I have now seen both episodes of a superb documentary made by a young American Jew, Matthew Cassel, and broadcast on Al Jazeera, the Qatari TV channel that these days specializes in brilliant in-depth documentary investigations of troubling world problems.
Young Cassel grew up in a Jewish family with the customary beliefs in relation to the establishment of Israel. But, troubled by certain aspects of the official story, he travelled to the Middle East, became a resident of Beirut for four years, and befriended many people who, after the Jewish takeover of Palestine in 1948, left their country to escape the war, believing that they would be returning in a few days.
For this documentary account of his doubts about the official story Cassel interviewed young people living in Israel today including those from both sides of the argument. One story he was told is that they were brought up in their schools to believe that Palestine was a land without people, for a people without land, a convenient  idea that I could not help comparing with the ignorant attitudes of Europeans who arrived in the New World more than 500 years ago equipped with the belief that they were entering an empty, unoccupied land, an idea they formalized into a legal concept called Terra Nullius, which they used as the  underpinning for their claim to have become owners of the land by virtue of their (so-called) discovery.
Cassel put his questions about the rights of the original owners of Palestine, the Palestinian inhabitants,  to young Israelis, both those born there and others more recently arrived, and got from many of them a casual shrug, and a “So what?”
In one unforgettable sequence in the first part of his investigation he follows a bus-load of Israelis taken to the West Bank by a dissident group established for that purpose. They are taken to a small city half an hour or an hour’s drive from Tel Aviv. This small  city was welded shut by the Israeli army years ago, and has stood there totally empty, ever since. One of the visitors stood in the middle of the deserted street and recalled how he had visited this place when it had been a busy, engaged and vibrant town. He looked around him and said he was staggered to see what had happened to it. He said that he had read of terrible tragedies that had overcome ethnic groups around the world, and added: “Now I find something every bit as bad has happened within a short drive of my own home. It is something I never knew about.”
In the second episode, Cassel recalls his close friendship with a Palestinian man who had been forced from his village in 1948, had lived in Lebanon since, always dreaming of visiting his home village, bringing up his children to know the sights and smells of this lost homeland that his family had been prevented from visiting for more than 60 years.  On his first visit Cassel, while friendly to the man, had not told him he was Jewish “because I thought it might be awkward for you if it was known you were friendly with a Jew.” Now he determined to tell him the truth. To prepare the occasion he went to a sports shop and bought a gift: a fishing rod for his friend whom he knew to be a keen fisherman. Then he told him that he had omitted to mention before that he had a Jewish mother who was unhappy about his activities in support of the Palestinian cause.  His friend replied immediately: “I do not care what you are. I care who you are. To me, you are a wholehearted supporter of the Palestinian cause. You are still my friend.”
In contrast, Cassel interviewed a recent arrival from the United States who had taken up residence in the village, claiming it as his ancestral right. A pleasant enough man, the arriving Jewish settler, when the question was put to him about the people whom he was replacing, said, “to me, I do not accept these arguments that they have been replaced and are longing to return. They left in 1948, and have no right to return to take over our land.”
Cassel invited his mother to express her feelings about the issue but she would not appear in the film, for fear of a negative reaction towards her from American Jews. But she wrote a letter explaining that in her youth the Holocaust was a more lively issue than it had since become to the generation of her son. To her it had carried the concept of shame. Her son commented: “I had not realized that aspect of shame,” but he added that to his mother Israel was right and must be supported whatever they did.
She added that they would simply have to agree to disagree, but that she still loved him as her son. And Matthew Cassel, reading the letter on camera, smiled and said, “I am her son again. That’s good.”
Still, he found her refusal to even discuss the issue indefensible. And in the last few minutes of the film that attitude was underlined by an attack mounted on water cannon by the Israeli army against protesting Palestinians, and by the explanation given by an official of how the Israelis were gradually, little by little, destroying Palestinian means of subsistence --- for example, a Jewish settlement of several dozen houses had been built on a hill overlooking a Palestinian farm whose water supply they had commandeered, by authority of the Israeli state.
This is a remarkable statement, this film --- calm, reasoned, impassioned and at the same time anguished, made by this young man, Matthew Cassel, who deserves the highest praise.

Contiguous with this investigation, AlJazeera has been showing a devastating inquiry called The Lost Cities of Palestine, an historical look at the state of Palestinian cities  up until 1948, cities like any other with their industries, infrastructure, governments, culture --- theatres, movies and the like --- fully functioning cities that were deliberately undermined, step by step, in fact, ruined, by the actions of the Israeli authorities. Another superb contribution to understanding of the dilemma that has exercised this area for almost the last century.

Friday, May 16, 2014

Link of the Day: May 15 2014: IMF finds Canada subsidizing the fossil fuel industry the staggering sum of $34 billion a year, hitherto unrecorded in the mainstream media!

International Monetary Fund
International Monetary Fund (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Mitchell Anderson, a freelance reporter in Vancouver, has come up with a killer story in The Tyee, the West Coast radical journal.Quoting the super-conservative International Monetary Fund, he reveals that Canada is subsidizing fossil fuel use to the extent of $34 billion a year. This is in the form of externalized costs pursuant to using transportation fuels; direct financial support to producer oil companies (these two items alone amounting to 20 times the budget of Environment Canada); similar remissions to natural gas companies (amounting to 44 per cent more than Canada’s annual international aid) and so on, making these subsidies higher as a proportion of government revenue than in any country except Luxembourg and the United States.

Enhanced by Zemanta